Deferment: Mindef can be flexible but must be fair too

Full-time National Service (NS) specialist cadets during a training exercise near Pasir Laba Camp.
Full-time National Service (NS) specialist cadets during a training exercise near Pasir Laba Camp.PHOTO: ST FILE

The Defence Ministry can be flexible on the issue of letting sportsmen and artists juggle their competitive commitments with their national service (NS) obligations more deftly. But it also has to be fair, Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen said in his first comments on the issue.

There must also be "a touch of practicality", ensuring that deferments are granted to those with "exceptional talent, who can bring honour and glory to Singapore", Dr Ng said last Friday in his annual media interview, ahead of SAF Day today.

While Mindef has routinely allowed short-term NS deferments for certain athletes ahead of major competitions, swimmer Joseph Schooling broke new ground in 2013 when it held off his enlistment until August next year to allow him to focus on training for the 2016 Olympics.

In granting long-term deferments of two to six years, Dr Ng said his ministry has to be "very careful because we want to be transparent".

"And there I'm keen, if we do it, to make it public, as we did for Joseph Schooling, so other Singaporeans know, and they can give feedback."

Dr Ng said the 20-year-old, who won nine gold medals at the recent SEA Games and whose gold medal at the Asiad last year was the first in 32 years for Singapore in men's swimming, was a "clear-cut case".

He said: "The way we approached this issue is, this person has the potential to win an Olympic medal, for instance... It was a clear-cut case, and I am sure, for clear-cut cases, if they were to write to me, I will respond similarly."

But the "tricky part" is when a person feels "special", when he may not be that exceptional. "The problem is when they don't meet the criteria and they say, 'If you give him a little bit more time, maybe he can meet the criteria' - that becomes more difficult," said Dr Ng.

Social and Family Development Minister Tan Chuan-Jin, who is president of the Singapore National Olympic Council, first suggested easing the criteria for NS deferment two weeks ago, adding that he hopes to work with Mindef to see if more flexible solutions can be worked out for sportsmen on a case-by-case basis.

Such a move will benefit the SEA Games' most bemedalled swimmer Quah Zheng Wen, who is due to enlist next month. If he does, it could throw into disarray his preparations for the Fina World Championships in Russia this month as well as the Rio Olympics next year.

It is understood that he has applied for deferment, but the issue has yet to be resolved.

Dr Ng said Mindef has been working with the Ministry of Culture, Community and Youth to give "as much latitude" to Team Singapore athletes to train so they can do well.

Of the 400 male athletes who participated in the SEA Games, about 30 were full-time national servicemen, who continued doing their full-time stints while training.

The majority of athletes were NSmen, who did not want short-term deferments, with only 24 taking up the offer, said Dr Ng. "They said, 'I can come and do my in-camp training and train at the same time, and win a medal.'"

Jermyn Chow

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on July 01, 2015, with the headline 'Deferment: Mindef can be flexible but must be fair too'. Print Edition | Subscribe