Want great teachers? Copying success stories isn't the answer

A school in Peshawar, Pakistan, on World Teachers' Day last Wednesday. In order to develop teacher quality, nations need to do far more than "borrow" policies from high-scoring nations. Nations can learn from one another, but this requires a systemat
A school in Peshawar, Pakistan, on World Teachers' Day last Wednesday. In order to develop teacher quality, nations need to do far more than "borrow" policies from high-scoring nations. Nations can learn from one another, but this requires a systematic exchange of information about sets of policies, not just identifying one promising approach.PHOTO: EUROPEAN PRESSPHOTO AGENCY

Most of us know the difference a good teacher makes in the life of a child. Many global institutions working to improve access to education, such as the United Nations, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, and Education International agree that "teacher quality" is the critical element in whether or not an educational system succeeds.

The UN has even called for "allocating the best teachers to the most challenging parts of a country, and providing teachers with the right mix of government incentives to remain in the profession and ensure all children are learning, regardless of their circumstances".

It is clear we need good teachers, but just what makes for "teacher quality"? And can quality be systematically improved by public policy?

For 30 years I have been studying cultural expectations of what makes a good teacher, beginning with field work in a Tibetan refugee school and an ethnographic study of Japanese and American public schools conducted some years later. More recently, my colleague Alex Wiseman and I have been working on what researchers from around the world consider to be "teacher quality".

The consensus is that teacher quality entails much more than just the way teachers deliver lessons in the classroom. Teacher quality is strongly affected by a teacher's working conditions. Teachers working long hours, with low pay, in crowded schools cannot give each student the attention they need.

Simply raising the requirements for teacher certification, based on what has worked in some high-performing countries, is not effective. An effective policy requires changes at the level of teacher recruitment, teacher education, and long-term support for professional development.


Around the world, more than a dozen nations have recently engaged in efforts to rapidly reform their teacher education and certification systems. The United States, along with nations as diverse as France, India, Japan and Mexico, has sought to improve its educational system by reforming teacher certification or teacher education.

Usually governments try to do this by passing laws listing more requirements for teachers to get their teaching certificate or licence. Often they look for models in countries that score well in international achievement tests like Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study, or Programme for International Student Assessment, such as Finland, Singapore and South Korea.

It is true that a teacher's qualifications, experience, personality and instructional skills all play a role in contributing to "quality". Teacher quality covers what teachers do outside the classroom: how responsive they are to parents and how much time they put into planning lessons or grading papers. Teaching certificates can make a difference towards ensuring teacher quality.

But that does not make for an effective policy. And here's the problem: One, merely focusing on standards like certification is not enough. Two, the effect can vary by grade level, or because of student background - so borrowing models from other countries is not the best strategy.

In the US, a key part of the important legislation No Child Left Behind was to put a "qualified teacher" in every classroom. The law emphasised certification, a college degree and content specialisation, but failed to identify teachers who knew how to implement reforms and who promoted critical thinking skills in their classrooms.

The most recent law addressing teacher quality, the Every Student Succeeds Act, had to roll back these requirements, allowing each state in the US to experiment with different ways to identify quality teaching.


Moreover, teacher quality is context-dependent: What works in one country may not work in another, or even for another group of students.

Let's take pre-school or early elementary teachers as an example. At this age, many parents would look for teachers who are warm, caring and understand child development. But this, as we know, would change for high school students.

In high school, especially in college preparation courses, students and parents expect teachers to focus on the lesson. The quality of their teaching is judged by how well their students score in tests, not how well they are developing socially or emotionally.

Goals of the educational system matter too. For example, American, Chinese and Japanese teachers take very different approaches to caring for small children and helping them learn basic academic skills. In the book Preschool In Three Cultures, educational anthropologist Joe Tobin and others show that Japanese pre-school teachers are comfortable with classes of 20 pupils, and tend to tolerate noise and disorder that most American teachers would find uncomfortable.

By contrast, American teachers place great emphasis on one-on-one interactions between children and adults, especially in helping children learn to express their feelings. It is possible that a competent, "high-quality" teacher from Japan would feel incompetent and confused in a US school, even if she was fluent in English.


That's not all. National conditions impact teacher quality. In some nations, it is a struggle to retain good teachers and distribute them evenly. For example, many low-income countries face challenges related to poverty, illness and labour shortages that create teacher shortages.

Mr Peter Wallet, a researcher at Unesco's Institute for Statistics, shows that in many countries, governments struggle to find enough teachers to staff their schools.

He writes: "The impact of HIV and Aids in Tanzania...meant that in 2006 an estimated 45,000 additional teachers were needed to make up for those who had died or left work because of illness."

The loss of so many teachers places many children at risk of having no access to quality teachers. This basic lack of qualified teachers has been identified by Unesco as the major barrier to providing access to quality education for all the world's children.

Even in wealthy nations, sometimes the most qualified teachers are concentrated in certain schools. In the US, there is a very unequal distribution of teachers between high- and low-income school districts.


Teaching is complex work. Teachers must build trust, increase motivation, research new methods of teaching, engage parents or caregivers and be adept at the social engineering of the classroom so that learning is not disrupted.

Effective teacher policy has to have at least three levels: It must provide clear goals for teacher education and skill development, provide "support to local institutions for the education of teachers", and address national demands for high-quality education.

In order to develop teacher quality, nations need to do far more than "borrow" policies from high-scoring nations. Nations can learn from one another, but this requires a systematic exchange of information about sets of policies, not just identifying one promising approach.

The International Summit on the Teaching Profession, an annual event that began in New York in 2011, is one example of this kind of global exchange that brings together governments and teacher unions for a dialogue.

To be effective, reforms need to have the support and input of teachers themselves. And, national and global leaders need to create more ways for teachers to provide suggestions, or criticism, of proposed reforms.

•The writer is an education professor at Pennsylvania State University

•This article first appeared in The Conversation (http://theconversation.com), a website that publishes analyses by academics and researchers.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on October 10, 2016, with the headline 'Want great teachers? Copying success stories isn't the answer'. Print Edition | Subscribe