The Straits Times says

Cleaning up after the FTX debacle

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

The precipitous decline and then bankruptcy last week of FTX, the world’s second-largest crypto exchange, is the biggest shock to the world’s crypto ecosystem since the collapse of the Terra-Luna stablecoin in May. It also serves as a reminder of how accident-prone the nascent industry continues to be. Although more details will emerge from the bankruptcy proceedings now under way, news reports and interviews with insiders indicate that the collapse of FTX had its origins in its links with a sister crypto trading firm called Alameda Research, to which it secretly transferred customer funds that were used for speculation. A lot of the assets on Alameda’s balance sheet included FTX’s own token, called FTT, which the company sought to use as collateral for loans. Substantial sales of FTT by one of its biggest holders, Binance, triggered the equivalent of a bank run. Unable to meet the redemption calls, Alameda was thus forced into bankruptcy, together with FTX.

The debacle has rippled across the entire crypto industry. The prices of crypto assets have tanked. Retail investors, whose holdings in FTX are frozen, have lost heavily. Blue-chip institutions such as venture capital firms Sequoia and SoftBank, and hedge fund Tiger Global, as well as Temasek, have each had hundreds of millions of dollars worth of investments in FTX wiped out. There will also be contagion. FTX had investments in more than 200 companies that maintained much of their assets on FTX. Several lenders, which hold now worthless FTT as collateral, will also be impaired.

But most seriously, the episode casts fresh doubts on the modus operandi and governance in the crypto industry as a whole. Regulators, such as the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, as well as the Justice Department, are investigating what happened at FTX. What is clear so far is that there was a lack of transparency around many of its activities, especially those conducted at its headquarters in the Bahamas. FTX’s implosion highlights the need for higher levels of regulatory scrutiny on the crypto industry, particularly on centralised exchanges as well as unregistered securities such as tokens.

The use of jurisdictional arbitrage, in which companies seek to benefit from lax regulations, is another issue that has to be addressed. The Monetary Authority of Singapore, too, should consider extending its regulations on digital payment token service providers to cover not just money laundering, terrorism financing and technology risks, but also safety and soundness, which can potentially impact not only retail investors but also institutions. And on their part, institutions will need to step up their due diligence when investing in the crypto ecosystem, in which, as the FTX disaster highlights, they have fallen short.

See more on