Forum: Skip AI and give children space to make mistakes and try again

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

One afternoon, my eight-year-old daughter was at home writing a reflection on a school trip to the park.

I guided her to recall what she had experienced, write down the main points, then write the reflection on paper before typing it into the Student Learning Space.

To my surprise, she typed her work into ChatGPT first.

She told me she wanted to make sure there were no grammatical mistakes.

I stopped her and asked her to use her original work, mistakes included.

It made me wonder: Is there no point in learning grammar, sentence structure and writing when artificial intelligence can correct them within seconds? Why read a book when artificial intelligence can summarise it?

I used to dislike rote learning. I could never understand why we had to practise the same thing repeatedly. Watching my daughter use ChatGPT made me reconsider this.

A child learning music practises the same scales again and again. There are wrong notes along the way. Over time, the child begins to recognise when a note does not sound right. Perhaps learning English, mathematics and science is not so different.

Making mistakes, being corrected and trying again are part of learning. If AI removes the mistakes before a child has had the chance to understand them, something may be lost in the process.

When everything becomes too perfect, it is no longer real.

School, especially at the primary level, should continue to give children space to learn the fundamentals, make mistakes and try again. It is also where they learn with others, form friendships, care for one another and experience being cared for.

Our children will grow up with AI. They should learn how to use it. But we should also ask what experiences we do not want AI to take away from them.

There will be plenty of time for my daughter to learn how AI can improve her writing. For now, I am happy to see grammatical mistakes in her schoolwork.

At least I know they are hers.

Loh Tick Boon

See more on