Forum: Should we pay people to be kind?

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

Singapore has recently seen more of what I call “pay-to-cultivate-good-habits” models like the Beverage Container Return Scheme and ReadSG.

If incentives work for recycling and reading, why not kindness? The 2025 Graciousness Survey by the Singapore Kindness Movement showed strong national belief in kindness, yet this doesn’t always translate into action, often because of inconvenience or hesitation. Can money provide the missing motivation?

Maybe. But while incentives might encourage more good deeds, they could also change what kindness means. There is an important difference between kindness and behaviours like recycling or reading. Containers returned can be counted, but kindness involves another person.

Beyond the act itself, intention and perceived motive matter. The Self-Determination Theory suggests that tangible rewards can weaken intrinsic motivation, an effect known as crowding out. If we pay people to help, will they continue once the rewards disappear?

Kindness is also hard to measure. A scheme can count volunteer hours or logged good deeds, which measure participation, not necessarily kindness. Worse, people might start chasing the reward over the outcome.

But I believe that some form of kindness is better than none, like how not everyone begins volunteering out of pure altruism. Students may volunteer to fulfil school requirements or make friends but can develop genuine empathy and volunteering interest along the way. Incentives can also remove practical barriers without turning kindness into transactions. Covering transport reimbursements, meals or flexible volunteering arrangements can make it easier for people to help.

Rather than asking how much to pay someone to help, perhaps we should ask what makes helping difficult in the first place. Recognition matters too and helps make kindness feel valued and possible.

So, should we pay people to be kind? My answer is no. Not because incentives are inherently bad, but because kindness is too important to be reduced to a transaction.

Irdina Auni
Editor, The Pride
Singapore Kindness Movement

See more on