Forum: Must civic responsibility always come with a financial reward?

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

I refer to the article “Singapore’s beverage container return scheme has been battered with criticisms. Why do we need it?” (Nov 3).

The criticisms surrounding Singapore’s Beverage Container Return Scheme, from rejected cans to the minor inconvenience of returning bottles for a ten-cent refund, raise a more fundamental question: Must civic responsibility always come with a financial reward?

Genuine civic pride should not require a deposit or the threat of a fine. My travels abroad have offered encouraging examples. In Japan, schoolchildren routinely clean their classrooms and school grounds, instilling a sense of responsibility and respect from a young age. In Taiwan, residents conscientiously sort their rubbish when collection trucks arrive. In Germany, recycling is firmly embedded in everyday life as part of a shared social responsibility.

Why have such values not become equally ingrained in our society?

Singapore has demonstrated its ability to transform itself remarkably, progressing from Third World to First within a generation.

We have cleaned up our rivers and streets, built an excellent public transport system and established a safe society with low crime rates and a strong reputation for integrity. These achievements are sources of genuine national pride.

The optimist in me hopes that one day, civic responsibility will become second nature to Singaporeans – not because of any pecuniary gain, but because of the kind of society we aspire to be.

Tan Hiok Seng

See more on