Forum: Make local vegetables affordable at places where consumers shop

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

Selling local vegetables directly to consumers through vending machines is a welcome attempt to shorten the supply chain and reduce distribution costs (Vending machines selling local veggies under $2 to be rolled out; support for fish farms to scale up, Oct 28).

But apart from vending machines, the harder task is matching supply with sustained consumer demand at competitive prices.

It was reported that the vending machines will sell lettuce and nai bai for $1.40 to $1.80 a pack through SG Farmers’ Market, compared with at least $2 for leafy greens under the same brand at FairPrice.

Comparing the lowest stated prices, supermarket prices are about 43% higher.

Although this is not an item-by-item comparison and does not establish supermarket margins, the gap raises a question: Could more have been done earlier to reduce the cost of bringing local produce to consumers?

More fundamentally, the benchmark should be the price of comparable imported vegetables, rather than local vegetables sold through another channel.

Consumers choosing between local and imported produce will consider the price and quality available at wet markets and supermarkets.

A lower price than another local offering does not necessarily make local produce competitive against imports. Nor does installing more vending machines, by itself, guarantee sufficient sales.

We should therefore explore further ways to remove costs throughout the supply chain.

One option is for local farmers to supply vegetables in bulk to wet-market stalls, where consumers already shop. Selling loose vegetables could reduce individual packaging costs and let consumers buy the quantities they need.

Farmers could also coordinate harvests and aggregate deliveries around stallholders’ orders, aligning production with demand.

Vending machines deserve a place in this effort.

But success should be measured by repeat purchases, lower wastage and viable returns for farmers, not by the number of machines installed.

The objective must be to make local vegetables consistently affordable and convenient wherever consumers already buy their food.

Liu Fook Thim

See more on