Forum: Is there an over-emphasis on perfection in our exam marking?

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

I received my child’s year-end examination results at the end of last month. A circuit drawing that was drawn correctly by my child in his science paper had a mark deducted because of a “gap” between the connecting wires marked out by the teacher. The gap was not visible to me on the paper.

After reading the requirements of the question, I struggled to understand why it was even marked wrong. The question mentioned there was “a” mistake in the circuit, and asked students to show what the correct circuit should look like.

My child had drawn the circuit showing the parallel arrangement, correcting the series arrangement in question. Didn’t this clearly demonstrate the understanding of concept that the question was testing?

I called up the school to find out the reason for the deducted mark. The school replied that this was according to the Ministry of Education marking scheme, and all gaps shown in the circuit would be marked wrong, as current cannot flow through the “gap”, resulting in an open circuit.

The writer's child had a mark deducted for a gap in the circuit.

The writer's child had a mark deducted for a gap in the circuit.

PHOTO: COURTESY OF ESTHER YEO

When my child pointed out that there were similar circuit drawings by other students with “gaps” that were marked correct, the school’s reply was that the gap is not as big as my child’s. How do schools ensure consistent marking when the size of the gap is subjective?

It is unnecessarily pedantic to split hairs to this extent. This reminds me of the case described in the commentary “When a correct answer is marked wrong, what are schools really testing?” (Aug 22).

The bar for perfection in our science examinations keeps getting higher, from the need for precise keywords to making sure every single detail is perfect. This will further exacerbate students’ examination woes.

I can now understand why our system inadvertently trains inflexible students who focus on perfecting answers, but cannot critically think out of the box.

Esther Yeo

See more on