Forum: Closing school windows during haze creates discomfort for students and teachers
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
When haze affects Singapore, schools face a dilemma.
Opening windows allows cross-ventilation, but may let polluted air inside. Closing them reduces the entry of outdoor pollutants, but classrooms can become hot and stuffy. Our children and teachers should not have to choose between cleaner air and a comfortable learning environment.
In a September 2025 parliamentary reply, the Ministry of Education (MOE) outlined its approach to keeping classrooms cool, including a north-south building orientation, shading, large window openings and ceiling fans. Extra measures include cool paint, more and faster fans, and more greenery. MOE also said it would continue exploring active cooling options for classrooms.
These measures have merit, but they do not fully address the dilemma when windows need to remain closed.
Although haze is often described as seasonal, prolonged periods of poor air quality remain a recurring risk. Schools should not have to improvise whenever haze persists. Preparedness should be built into school infrastructure, not left to ad hoc measures when haze arrives.
The health implications deserve greater attention. Haze particles can irritate the eyes, nose and throat, and aggravate existing respiratory and heart conditions. Prolonged exposure to excessive heat can cause dehydration and heat-related illness, while discomfort can make concentration and learning more difficult. Children with underlying health conditions may be particularly vulnerable, while teachers face these conditions throughout their work day.
Air purifiers can help reduce the amount of airborne particles, but they do not cool classrooms. Fans circulate air, but cannot remove heat when windows are closed. A solution that addresses both indoor air quality and thermal comfort is needed.
This does not mean air-conditioning must run indiscriminately. Singapore can explore energy-efficient cooling systems combining air-conditioning, appropriate ventilation and effective particle filtration, with sensible temperature settings and a phased roll-out to manage costs and energy use.
MOE has acknowledged the need to explore active cooling. It is time to move towards a concrete plan with clear standards for classroom temperatures and indoor air quality.
If children’s health is fundamental to learning, why should the air they breathe and the heat they endure be secondary concerns? When haze forces windows to be closed, our schools should already have an answer.
Hu Wenyan
