Forum: Are we doing enough to make our roads safer for vulnerable users?

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

The deaths of three cyclists on three consecutive days (Nov 11 to 13) are distressing.

While resources for road safety are limited, they should be prioritised according to the potential harm involved. Greater attention and enforcement should be directed at those who can cause serious injury or death, rather than placing disproportionate emphasis on the protective behaviour of those most at risk.

Parliamentary questions and ministerial replies over the past decade reveal two recurring areas of scrutiny: behaviour that may endanger others, and the habits or protective equipment of those who may get hurt.

A pedestrian can be reminded to look carefully, but that does not slow an approaching vehicle. A cyclist can wear a helmet, but it offers little protection against the impact of a heavy vehicle.

Safer road design works. Silver Zones have reduced accidents involving senior pedestrians by about 80%, while red-amber-green turn arrows have reduced accidents involving right turns by about 40%.

We should build on these successes by prioritising physical speed-calming measures at accident-prone pedestrian crossings, junctions and turning points; reviewing road layouts where vulnerable users interact with heavy vehicles; and giving greater enforcement attention to dangerous driving behaviours, including speeding, failure to give way and unsafe turning movements, which put others at serious risk.

Road safety education and personal responsibility remain important. However, they cannot compensate for dangerous road design or inadequate control of vehicle speeds. A road-safety system should not depend on everyone behaving perfectly. It should be designed to minimise harm when people make mistakes.

Francis Chu

See more on