Forum: Anticipating diseases serves high-risk patients and communities better
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
We thank See Hui Ti for her Forum letter, “Not every healthy choice needs to become a medical claim” (Sept 8), in response to our commentary.
We are glad she agrees with us that non-pharmaceutical and non-medical device-related funding should be made available for appropriate patients and high-risk individuals. We also agree that the evidence threshold should be robust before permitting such funding.
On See’s concern about limits, a “limiting principle” as she proposes is implicit in our article. We had called for funding only interventions tied to defined risk profiles and measurable outcomes, re-assessed on a set schedule, and not activities claimable simply because they are broadly healthy.
A structured falls-prevention programme for an assessed high-risk senior, with a re-evaluation checkpoint, fits this; general gym membership or running shoes would not.
Where we diverge is in the timing of funded interventions. See adopts a typical reactive approach in which disease adjuncts are funded once patients have known disease. We eschew this and advocate instead for identifying high-risk patients for, say, frailty and falls and intervening early before disease onset.
We believe being anticipatory and proactive serves residents and communities better. Finally, we wholeheartedly agree that “not every healthy choice needs to be a medical claim”.
Likewise, not every medical claim needs to be based on a drug or device too. We have to take a broader view of what contributes to better health outcomes for Singaporeans and direct resources accordingly.
Jeremy Lim
Cheryl Chong
