In one of the world’s densest cities, peace and quiet are hard to find. As a global hub, Singapore’s skies are always busy, while an extensive web of roads and a well-connected MRT network keep residents constantly on the move. But these conveniences come at a noisy price – the traffic never stops, and for those living nearby, the constant sound is often impossible to escape.

“Singapore’s land scarcity forces housing, schools and workplaces to be built immediately adjacent to expressways, arterial roads, viaducts and busy vehicle corridors,” explained Professor Gan Woon-Seng, who teaches audio engineering at National Technological University (NTU). Additionally, “most residential buildings are high-rise, creating multiple reflection canyons where noise bounces between buildings”.

Moreover, in the city’s hot climate, many residents prefer open-window living, allowing more noise into houses.

To understand how this never-ending noise invades homes, we collaborated with Prof Gan and senior research engineer Santi Peksi from NTU’s Smart Nation Translation Lab. With their help, we recorded sound levels inside 25 residences across the city. All the participants live near a source of steady traffic, such as an airport, a major road or the MRT .

The recordings captured the noise landscape in each home. To make sense of what we found, we first need to talk about decibels.

Safe and unsafe decibels

Decibels are used to measure the intensity of sound. Louder noises correspond to higher decibels. A quiet library is roughly 40dB, while drilling at a construction site is about 76dB. Hear for yourself.

The following clips won’t play at their actual decibel levels; that depends on your device and volume settings. What matters is the relative difference: Listen to how much louder one environment is compared to another.

Woodlands library
40dB
Interior of MRT cabin in transit

60dB is 4x louder than 40dB

60dB
Drilling at Braddell MRT station
76dB

The tricky thing about decibels is that they increase not linearly, but on a logarithmic scale. That means when noise jumps from 20dB to 40dB, the sound is not twice as loud, but 4 times as loud. Because of this, little changes in decibels make a big impact.

According to the WHO, excessive noise can cause an array of unwanted health problems – from sleep disturbance and depression to hypertension and adverse birth outcomes – so the organisation has established safe levels of average exposure. For traffic noise, it recommends a daily average of less than 53dB, and less than 45dB for aircraft noise.

Singapore, too, has determined safe levels of noise. The National Environment Agency (NEA) suggests average indoor noise levels should be below 57dB.

“These benchmarks were established by referencing international standards,” said an NEA spokesperson.

The slightly lower WHO level can be tough to achieve in Singapore. “The WHO road traffic noise thresholds are derived largely from European exposure datasets,” Prof Gan explained. “When applied to dense Asian cities, structural, climatic and land-use realities make these thresholds systematically more difficult to achieve, even with strong governance and high-quality infrastructure.”

With the help of Ms Santi, ST analysed up to six hours of recorded noise in each of the 25 homes we visited. A true comparison with WHO and NEA standards would require a full day of recording. Nonetheless, during the hours we visited, the noise in many homes reached levels that, if sustained throughout the day, would exceed both the WHO and NEA safe noise thresholds.

These numbers tell one story. But to really understand what living with excessive noise means, you need to hear it for yourself.

Paya Lebar
1.5km from airbase

Ms Ong’s apartment sits just 1.5km from Paya Lebar Air Base. Her daily soundtrack is the roar of passing planes.

As jets thunder overhead, the noise jumps to 72dB. Over one hour on a weekday afternoon, similar noise spikes happened 8 times.

These spikes make a big impact on the average noise intensity, lasting as long as 40 seconds.

We looked at three other homes near airports. In all of them, the passing aircraft were intrusive and loud. Some noises spiked more than 20dB above the average levels in the homes.

Next, let’s go to Ms Teoh’s home in Ang Mo Kio. She lives on the 20th floor, just 85m away from an MRT track.

While those near the airport experience loud spikes of sound, Ms Teoh lives with a more constant level of noise. Much of it comes from the train’s screeching brakes.

The repetitive noises last around 20 seconds. Some are as loud as 66dB.

We visited two other homes near the MRT. These train noises, hovering between 53dB and 63dB, are relatively soft compared with the sounds of air traffic.

Finally, this is Mr Ong’s home. He lives in Sengkang, 26m from a four-lane intersection where vehicles continuously start and stop.

Here, noise fluctuates in an almost cyclic manner. An assortment of sounds repeats over and over, ranging from sirens to honks.

Some sounds are particularly loud: The siren spiked at 77dB.

While the noises that Mr Ong experiences are quite repetitive, other homes near major roads don’t endure the same. Here are three more we visited. All experience an array of sounds, from motorcycles to buses.

Not all sounds are equal

The noise from road traffic and a waterfall can be the same volume, but one sounds peaceful, while the other is intrusive. The difference isn’t in the loudness, but in how our brains interpret the sound.

“Although noise metrics such as decibels provide standardised physical quantification of sound energy, human response to noise is fundamentally subjective,” explained Prof Gan. “Two sounds with identical sound pressure levels can evoke very different perceptions.”

Psychoacoustic researchers have identified several metrics, beyond just volume, that contribute to what makes a noise annoying. Two important ones are sharpness and roughness.

Roughness describes how grating or buzzing a sound feels. It is caused by rapid fluctuations that make a sound harsh or unpleasant. Sharpness, meanwhile, measures how piercing or shrill a sound is.

Motorcycle rev

0.215 asper
Sound animation Motorcycle rev

Motorcycle rev

0.154 asper
Sound animation Motorcycle rev

Motorcycle rev

0.091 asper
Sound animation Motorcycle rev

Tap to listen

Helicopter

0.081 asper
Sound animation Helicopter

Plane

0.057 asper
Sound animation Plane

Motorcycle rev

0.050 asper
Sound animation Motorcycle rev

Motorcycle rev

0.044 asper
Sound animation Motorcycle rev

Train

0.036 asper
Sound animation Train

Heavy vehicle brake

0.035 asper
Sound animation Heavy vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

0.033 asper
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Plane

0.032 asper
Sound animation Plane

Train

0.031 asper
Sound animation Train

Engine exhaust

0.030 asper
Sound animation Engine exhaust

Heavy vehicle brake

0.029 asper
Sound animation Heavy vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

0.028 asper
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

0.026 asper
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

0.026 asper
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Train

0.025 asper
Sound animation Train

Engine exhaust

0.024 asper
Sound animation Engine exhaust

Engine exhaust

0.021 asper
Sound animation Engine exhaust

Roughest
sound

Heavy vehicle brake

2.71 acum
Sound animation Heavy vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

2.42 acum
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

2.15 acum
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Tap to listen

Heavy vehicle brake

1.99 acum
Sound animation Heavy vehicle brake

Vehicle brake

1.84 acum
Sound animation Vehicle brake

Motorcycle

1.77 acum
Sound animation Motorcycle

Train

1.66 acum
Sound animation Train

Heavy vehicle brake

1.54 acum
Sound animation Heavy vehicle brake

Vehicle acceleration

1.47 acum
Sound animation Vehicle acceleration

Motorcycle

1.44 acum
Sound animation Motorcycle

Vehicle acceleration

1.39 acum
Sound animation Vehicle acceleration

Vehicle acceleration

1.28 acum
Sound animation Vehicle acceleration

Train

1.19 acum
Sound animation Train

Motorcycle

1.18 acum
Sound animation Motorcycle

Train

1.15 acum
Sound animation Train

Train

1.13 acum
Sound animation Train

Plane

1.10 acum
Sound animation Plane

Horn

1.04 acum
Sound animation Horn

Motorcycle rev

0.96 acum
Sound animation Motorcycle rev

Plane

0.69 acum
Sound animation Plane

Roughest
sound

To explain sharpness and roughness, we isolated some of the loudest traffic noises in our recordings.

Let’s start with the whine of a motorcycle. We will explore its roughness, which is how harsh or unpleasant it sounds.

These lines represent a sound without any roughness. Roughness is measured in asper, a unit that quantifies the fast, irregular changes in sound. Watch how the lines change when we introduce roughness.

asper-legend/

This is the sound of a motorcycle. Its roughness measures 0.0375 asper, which we’ve represented graphically with these jagged waves.

As the motorcycle gets closer, and then passes by, its roughness increases to 0.0915 asper. We often find sounds with greater roughness to be more unpleasant.

These are 20 noises arranged from highest to lowest roughness. Notice how the engine exhaust with the lowest asper sounds smooth, while the motorcycle and helicopter sound more coarse.

Here is the roughness of a vehicle braking. If you listen, you may make out another annoying quality – a piercing or shrill sound. This is sharpness.

Graphically, we’ll show sharpness by making the wavelength longer or shorter. Sharpness is measured by acum, which quantifies the unpleasantness of higher frequencies.

asper-legend

The screech from the vehicle brakes is 2.47 acum.

Now, the noises are arranged from highest to lowest sharpness. The plane with the lowest acum exudes stable low frequencies, while the high-acum brake screeches give us the “ick”.

When organised into quadrants, we see how the combination of these qualities changes how a sound “feels”. For most of us, the sounds in the top-right corner – high roughness and high sharpness – will be most annoying.

Noise pollution is the ‘new second-hand smoke’

Excessive noise isn’t just annoying, it’s a serious health concern. According to WHO, noise from road traffic is the second-most harmful environmental stressor, behind air pollution.

“When something stresses you, it affects the immune system,” said Dr Omar Hahad, researcher at Germany’s University Medical Center of Mainz. “And when this is disturbed, literally every organ’s system is affected.”

Noise pollution can cause hearing damage, poor sleep, depression and anxiety. It can also contribute to heart disease, dementia, diabetes, increased infection rates and Alzheimer’s.

“We see that even one night of traffic noise increases vascular dysfunction, increases heart rate and blood pressure, and increases stress hormone release,” said Dr Hahad. These consequences are found in both healthy and unhealthy patients alike, but are worse in older populations and those with existing risk factors.

Because of these widespread health effects, some researchers have started referring to noise pollution as the “new second-hand smoke”.

“Second-hand means that, even if you’re not smoking, you’re affected by it,” said Dr Hahad. “Like (with noise) when there are night flights and a lot of traffic – you’re not responsible for that, but you’ll get affected by it.”

And it gets more complicated. Dr Hahad said noise pollution affects not just individuals’ health, but also their health behaviour. “When you’re exposed to noise, you’re less physically active, you tend to take alcohol and cigarettes because people are looking for easy coping pathways.” These behaviours, in turn, also increase health risks.

Excessive noise is a system-wide problem

Many of those we surveyed said they actively take measures to combat the noise. The most common was simply closing the window. But it’s hard for individuals to tackle the root problem.

“We, as healthcare providers, cannot reduce the noise levels of our patients, so we need political energy to reduce this,” said Dr Hahad. “You could say ‘have a better diet’ and ‘be more physically active’, but you cannot tell a patient to lower their noise because they cannot move (homes). This needs collaborative action between healthcare providers and lawmakers.”

Singapore has a handful of military air bases and two commercial airports, including Changi – the world’s 15th largest by passenger numbers – which makes managing aircraft noise a big job.

Ms Jean Yee, director of air navigation services policy at the Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore, said: “Singapore adopts the International Civil Aviation Organization’s balanced approach to aircraft noise management.” This means departing planes at Changi use special routes that avoid flying over noise-sensitive areas during take-off. Between midnight and 6am, arriving aircraft must use quieter engine settings, unless necessary, and the runway closest to residential areas is closed entirely.

Roads occupy 12 per cent of Singapore’s total land area. To reduce noise from this extensive network, Singapore’s Land Transport Authority (LTA) installs barriers along expressways and flyovers, and uses special low-noise pavement on some expressways.

“When implementing traffic noise mitigation measures, our key considerations include road noise levels in relation to proximity of residential developments and noise-sensitive developments,” said an LTA spokesperson. “Mitigation measures are prioritised in areas where noise levels exceed acceptable thresholds, particularly near homes, schools and healthcare facilities.”

LTA also manages noise mitigation measures for the MRT. Noise barriers are installed along parts of the MRT located near homes, and also where sound levels exceed NEA guidelines. LTA also works with manufacturers to fit trains with noise-dampening wheels and modify elevated tracks to better absorb vibration and noise.

For new residential developments, NEA has implemented noise impact guidelines and assessments, which ensure new buildings keep out as much traffic clamour as possible.

The agency also suggests measures that individuals can take: “To further reduce noise levels, residents may consider additional measures such as closing their windows, installing noise curtains or using laminated or double-glazed windows.”

Despite the many noise mitigation measures implemented by the city, there is more that can be done. “Agencies can use noise mapping, predictive modelling and real-time sensor networks to guide interventions,” Prof Gan suggested. This kind of monitoring system could identify shifting noise hot spots.

He also said Singapore could establish urban design guidelines that don’t just aim to reduce decibels, but also consider psychoacoustic metrics like the variety and pleasantness of the soundscape.

For now, many Singaporeans will have to accept that dense urban living comes with a soundtrack. But, as the city and researchers have shown, solutions exist. With continued collaboration between health experts, urban planners and policymakers, Singapore can ensure that its residents don’t have to choose between city living and a good night’s sleep.