How Metallica keep their concerts fresh after 40 years
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
Metallica in concert at the MetLife Stadium in New Jersey, on Aug 4. The band set an ambitious goal about 20 years ago - never play the same set list twice.
PHOTO: NYTIMES
NEW YORK – In Metallica’s frenetic 1983 ode to headbanging, Whiplash, the American band’s guitarist and lead singer James Hetfield barks: “We’ll never stop, we’ll never quit, ’cause we’re Metallica.”
Somehow, across four decades marked by success but also death, addiction and at least one very public near-implosion, the band have kept their word.
In 2023, Metallica released their 11th full-length studio album, 72 Seasons. Their debut LP, Kill ’Em All, also turned 40, just days before the quartet arrived in New Jersey for the first North American date on their M72 World Tour. They are not the only band doing stadium tours, even as the members are around the age of 60. Not every band make their bones slamming through songs that regularly top 190 beats a minute.
That tenacity was evident on a Friday night earlier in August at MetLife Stadium as the tour touched down in East Rutherford. Drums pounded. Riffs chugged. Solos melted the faces off an all-ages crowd of about 80,000, dressed almost exclusively in black.
But how does a band keep it fresh after, by drummer Lars Ulrich’s count, performing Master Of Puppets (1986) 1,697 times onstage? The answer is by constantly mixing it up, said Ulrich, who creates the band’s set lists on the day of each show – a “safeguard against ending up on autopilot”.
That may sound obvious, but it was not always the case. “Thirty years ago, we took going out and executing a set really seriously,” he said over the telephone last week, when the goal was nailing everything “almost like in a robotic way”.
Metallica – who also feature guitarist Kirk Hammett and bassist Robert Trujillo – started fiddling with their encores and covers as their catalogue kept growing. About 20 years ago, on the St Anger tour, the group set an ambitious goal – never play the same set list twice.
Metallica in concert, at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, on Aug 4.
“Mixing it up” with the set list is a surprisingly complex affair. Metallica productions go big, and the band’s elaborate programme of pyrotechnics, lighting and interstitial audio-video, among other flourishes – the New Jersey show included a drop of giant black-and-yellow beach balls – has historically discouraged major changes to the list. Having four drum kits this time did not simplify things.
Eventually, the band developed what Ulrich called a “slot” system based on the band’s different “food groups” of songs, a reference to their feel and tempo.
Slot 1 (of 16) on the M72 tour, for example, will always be an upper-mid-tempo fan favourite – Day 1 at MetLife, it was Creeping Death (1984) – that has a quickly recognisable opening riff, not too fast or complicated.
But the songs in that slot will rotate. Slot 10 should always be a ballad, like Nothing Else Matters (1991). The closer is always Master Of Puppets or Enter Sandman (1991).
Ulrich spoke about the set list from that first night at MetLife. These are edited excerpts from the conversation.
Creeping Death
“What makes a good opening song? I mean, ask a hundred people, you get a hundred different answers. So, none of this is science. But, after a while, you start figuring out instinctively that this song maybe works better than this other one. Often when you are touring on the back of an album, the default is to open with the opening track of the album that you’re touring with. I wanted purposely to not do that, just to sort of challenge ourselves.”
72 Seasons
Kirk Hammett and James Hetfield of Metallica in concert, at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, on Aug 4.
“72 Seasons is the opening song on the latest album, and it’s also the title track. It has a real forward motion and a lot of energy, and it’s representative and indicative of the headspace, mood and energy of the new album. So, it feels like a great way to kind of introduce what we’re doing these days.
“The title refers to the first 18 years of your life. In broad strokes, it’s basically the idea that the first 72 seasons of your life shape who you become, for better or worse. And as you move through life, you’re trying to expand on those experiences, or maybe shake them, get away from them.”
Fade To Black
“We’re all very open about where we’re at with our moods and all of us dealing with various levels of mental health. And that feels like it’s less of a taboo than it was, say, 20 or 30 years ago. James, increasingly, is very comfortable onstage talking about how he’s doing and feeling, and often he’ll send Fade To Black (1984) off with some personal thoughts or something that relates to how he’s doing at that moment.
“The takeaway message is that you’re not alone, and we’re in this together. I’m an only child. I’ve struggled with being an outsider and a loner all my life. And, you know, being in a band, playing concerts and all, that is the best remedy for me to feel that I’m not alone.”
Orion
Metallica's James Hetfield at the MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, on Aug 4.
“Orion (1986) is one that we have enjoyed playing a little bit more in recent years. We opened with it when we played with The Rolling Stones. It has a unique palette and illustrates the different songwriting inspirations and influences that exist within Metallica.
“When we’re playing it, the spirit of Cliff Burton (a former Metallica bassist, who died in a 1986 bus crash) is definitely present in the building. And Robert channels Cliff’s spirit in the part that he’s playing so incredibly well. It’s a beautiful, beautiful moment.”
Master Of Puppets
“Master Of Puppets is the song we’ve played the most live. It’s been a part of every tour since we released it. It got a significant, unexpected boost in 2022, when it became part of the (Netflix fantasy series) Stranger Things finale.
“And who would’ve thought that a 37-year-old song that’s more than eight minutes long and is pretty heavy throughout would resonate in the way that it does with a new and younger generation of listeners? But how crazy cool is that?” NYTIMES
