China banks prepare for worst-case scenario

SHANGHAI • Just as it looked like Beijing was starting to get a handle on its regional banking crisis, a much more severe threat is engulfing the world's largest banking system as a deadly new virus hits the country's economy.

The impact of the spreading coronavirus risks bringing to life the worst-case economic scenarios contained in China's annual banking stress tests.

Last year's exercise envisaged annual economic growth slowing to as little as 4.15 per cent - a scenario which showed that the bad-loan ratio at the nation's 30 biggest banks would rise fivefold. Analysts now say that the outbreak could send first-quarter growth down to as little as 3.8 per cent.

Banks are already suffering record loan defaults as the economy last year expanded at the slowest pace in three decades. The slump tore through the nation's US$41 trillion (S$57 trillion) banking system, forcing the first bank seizure in two decades and bailouts of two other key lenders.

"The banking industry is taking a big hit," said National Institution for Finance and Development analyst You Chun. "The outbreak has already damaged China's most vibrant small businesses, and if it prolongs, many firms will go under and be unable to repay their loans."

The virus outbreak comes on top of an unresolved trade dispute with the United States. With many banks under-capitalised, it may put even the nation's heavyweight lenders, often called on to support growth, in danger from the growing stress.

Economic growth is seen plummeting this quarter, even amid heavy cash injections from the central bank. Whether that stagnation will carry through to the rest of the year depends on how quickly the authorities can get a handle on the spreading virus and get the nation's economic engines running again.

UBS Group estimates China's economic growth will slow to 3.8 per cent in the first quarter from a 6 per cent pace at the end of last year, and to 5.4 per cent for this year if the virus is contained within three months.

If the virus situation is more protracted, annual growth could dip below 5 per cent, UBS said. Goldman Sachs Group also predicts a sharp slowdown in the quarter to 4 per cent, while still predicting full-year growth at 5.5 per cent.

Doing its own calculations based on China's stress tests, debt rating firm S&P Global estimates that the worst-case scenario would cause bad debt to balloon by 5.6 trillion yuan (S$1.1 trillion) for a ratio of about 6.3 per cent, adding to the already daunting 2.4 trillion yuan of non-performing loans China's banks are sitting on.

Banks with operations concentrated in Hubei province and its capital city of Wuhan, the epicentre and region worst hit by the virus, are likely to see the greatest increase in problem loans.

DAMAGE FROM OUTBREAK

The banking industry is taking a big hit. The outbreak has already damaged China's most vibrant small businesses, and if it prolongs, many firms will go under and be unable to repay their loans. 

NATIONAL INSTITUTION FOR FINANCE & DEVELOPMENT ANALYST YOU CHUN

The region had 4.6 trillion yuan of outstanding loans doled out by 160 local and foreign banks at the end of 2018, with more than half in Wuhan. The five big state banks had 2.6 trillion yuan of exposure in the region, followed by 78 local rural lenders, according to official data.

Moreover, policymakers have once again enlisted the largest lenders, including the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), to serve their civic duty by bailing out millions of struggling small businesses, and to do that by providing more cheap loans, rolling over debt and waiving fees.

Officials on Friday sought to ease concern over the hit to the banking sector. Mr Zhou Liang, vice-chairman of the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission, said that a potential increase in bad loans is manageable.

Chinese lenders dissolved three trillion yuan of bad loans last year alone, he said, adding that the bad-loan ratio of China's small businesses was at 3.22 per cent.

Highlighting the plight of small businesses, a recent nationwide survey showed that about 30 per cent said they expect to see revenue plunge more than 50 per cent this year because of the virus, and 85 per cent said they are unable to maintain operations for more than three months with the cash currently available.

"Social stability is of utmost importance to the authorities in China," S&P analysts led by Mr Tan Ming said in a recent report. "Therefore, banks have been asked to help carry the burden of this health outbreak."

While most state banks agreed to cut the borrowing costs of virus-stricken firms by 0.5 percentage point, the State Council now requires them to ensure that small businesses are paying no more than 1.6 per cent with government subsidy.

Even as cheaper financing may help the broader economy, rates below 5 per cent mean banks are barely making enough money to cover their cost of funding after accounting for default risks, people familiar with the matter have said.

A major difference from the 2008 global financial crisis, or the 2003 outbreak of Sars, "is the lack of bank capital now to support an aggressive bank-led credit stimulus", said Ms Grace Wu, head of Greater China Banks at Fitch Ratings in Hong Kong. "Chinese banks do not have the same capacity to replenish capital now, given their profitability has trended down in recent years."

And investors are turning more downbeat on the Chinese banks whose shares have underperformed against the benchmark in most of the past five years. The "big four" state-owned lenders, which together control more than US$14 trillion of assets, currently trade at an average of 0.6 times their forecast book value, near a record low.

ICBC fell 1.8 per cent in Hong Kong as of 9.50am yesterday, extending this year's decline to 11 per cent, while China Construction Bank, the nation's second largest, has lost 7.6 per cent so far this year.

The unexpected epidemic is now their greatest test.

"The resilience of China's banking system may be severely tested," the S&P analysts said.

BLOOMBERG

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on February 11, 2020, with the headline 'China banks prepare for worst-case scenario'. Print Edition | Subscribe