Afghan-style democracy faces test in legislative election

Election candidate Abdul Jabar Qahraman was blown up on Oct 17, 2018, by a bomb placed under his sofa in the southern province of Helmand. At least 10 election candidates have been killed so far.
Election candidate Abdul Jabar Qahraman was blown up on Oct 17, 2018, by a bomb placed under his sofa in the southern province of Helmand. At least 10 election candidates have been killed so far.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

KABUL (AFP) - At least 10 election candidates have been killed, thousands of polling centres closed, and many voters are likely to stay home due to the threat of militant attacks.

This is democracy, Afghanistan style.

Almost nine million people have registered to vote in Saturday's (Oct 20) parliamentary election, which is more than three years late and only the third since the fall of the Taleban in 2001.

But shambolic preparations, expectations of industrial-scale fraud, and escalating poll-related violence threaten to derail the election, which the international community is advising and largely funding.

"We're trying to make a terrible situation slightly less bad," a Western diplomat told Agence France-Presse (AFP), reflecting a sharp drop in expectations for a credible result, even by Afghan standards.

Alarm is growing as the beleaguered Independent Election Commission (IEC), which has been skewered for its poor handling of the process, struggles to distribute voting materials to more than 5,000 polling centres before they open at 7am on Saturday local time (10.30am Singapore time).

They are supposed to include biometric voter verification devices that Afghan political leaders and officials agreed to use only a few weeks ago and have been made mandatory, despite being untested and not required by law.

 
 
 

Votes cast without the controversial machines will not be counted, IEC spokesman Sayed Hafizullah Hashimi told AFP, even though polling centre workers have received little or no training in how to use them.

Observers are concerned the results could be thrown into turmoil if the devices are broken, lost or destroyed.

There also are fears the data could be manipulated before preliminary results are released on Nov 10.

"Using technology can help transparency but it can also create confusion if not used properly," said Mr Naeem Ayubzada, director of the Transparent Election Foundation of Afghanistan.

More than 2,500 candidates are competing for 249 seats in the lower house, including doctors, mullahs, the sons of former warlords, and at least one prisoner.

Campaigning has been marred by violence. At least 10 candidates have been killed so far, including Mr Abdul Jabar Qahraman who was blown up on Wednesday (Oct 17) by a bomb placed under his sofa in the southern province of Helmand.

The Taleban has warned candidates to withdraw from the ballot, which it has vowed to attack, and told education workers to stop their schools from being used as polling centres.

The election is seen as a rehearsal for the presidential vote scheduled for next April and an important milestone ahead of a United Nations meeting in Geneva in November, where Afghanistan is under pressure to show progress on "democratic processes".

Despite speculation the vote could be postponed again, Mr Hashimi said it had to go ahead on time.

"It is already snowing in some provinces and the weather is getting colder," Mr Hashimi told AFP. "If we delay the elections for a week, it means we won't have them."

Observers expect turnout on polling day to be far lower than the 8.9 million registered to vote in the first legislative election since 2010.

More than 2,000 voting centres have already been closed for security reasons, and the threat of more militant attacks are likely to persuade many voters to avoid the poll.

Some 54,000 members of Afghanistan's already overstretched security forces will be deployed to protect the ballot.

To help boost numbers, Mr Hashimi on Wednesday urged the media to focus on the elections, not violence.

There are widespread suspicions that a significant number of voter registrations were based on fake identification documents, which fraudsters hope to use to stuff ballot boxes.

Registrations in the eastern province of Paktia, for example, were "an implausible" 141 per cent of the estimated eligible population, Afghanistan Analysts Network (AAN) said in a recent report.

"The fraud is already baked in," a Western diplomat told AFP, adding that Afghan officials may never know how many people actually voted.

That has further eroded confidence and deterred potential voters.

"Most of the people I have been talking to say they won't go to vote, some even didn't bother to register, and many said 'we would love to vote if we knew the system would work'," AAN co-director Thomas Ruttig told AFP.

"It's not that Afghans are tired of democracy. They're tired of this kind of pseudo-democracy."