Indonesia police chief urges discretion in enforcing Internet law

JAKARTA • Indonesia's police chief has called on officers to use greater discretion when enforcing the country's Internet law, following signs from the government that the legislation, which has ensnared journalists, academics and opposition figures, will be reviewed.

The 2008 electronic information and transactions law (ITE), which regulates online activity including defamation and hate speech, has long drawn criticism for its broad interpretation.

In a circular issued on Monday, national police chief Listyo Sigit Prabowo urged officers to use discretion when investigating reports of digital infringements, and to prioritise "restorative justice" such as mediation rather than prosecution.

The guidelines, he said, had been issued in response to the law's application, "which is considered to be contradicting the public's right to freedom of expression in the digital space".

Between 2016 and 2020, there were 786 cases involving the law, with 88 per cent of those charged ending up behind bars, according to Mr Damar Juniarto of digital advocacy group, the Southeast Asia Freedom of Expression Network.

In 2019, a woman in Lombok, Ms Baiq Nuril, was jailed for six months after recording a telephone conversation with her boss, to prove he was sexually harassing her, that was later shared online.

"I was once a victim," Ms Nuril, who was eventually pardoned by President Joko Widodo, told Reuters. "I don't want any more victims."

The same year, an Indonesian singer and opposition figure was sentenced to one year in prison after calling his political rivals idiots in a video blog.

"This (law) is a big rock that is hard to move, that is really blocking democracy," said Mr Damar.

Earlier this month, President Joko said the law must be implemented "as fairly as possible" and meet the public's sense of justice, while the chief security minister announced this week that a team has been formed to review the law.

But Mr Damar said he was concerned the team did not include independent parties and might not make substantive changes.

"I'm afraid this will only end up by making the guidance for interpretation," he said, and not touch on reform.

REUTERS

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on February 24, 2021, with the headline 'Indonesia police chief urges discretion in enforcing Internet law'. Subscribe