Hong Kong property tycoons bank on middle class to weather tough times

HONG KONG (REUTERS) - When things get choppy at the top of the property ladder, it pays to have your feet planted on the middle rungs, which makes developers Cheung Kong (Holdings) and Sun Hung Kai Properties the best bets to weather the storm brewing in Hong Kong.

These powerful property developers are targeting middle-class, first-time buyers who are exempt from the impact of government cooling measures at a time when secondary home transactions are hovering at a 17-year low.

"This represents a large potential market for developers launching new projects, so long as they price units affordably and draw first-time buyers from the secondary to the primary market," said Mr Raymond Liu, a property analyst at brokerage Macquarie. First-time buyers comprised 70 per cent of the market last year, up from 53 per cent in 2011, Mr Liu said.

With 45 per cent of its saleable units this year aimed at mass-market buyers, the highest among its peers, Macquarie has identified Sun Hung Kai as a potential winner in this market, although success will come at the expense of profit margins.

It ranked Henderson Land Development second with 37 per cent of its new launches considered "affordable", or below the HK$6 million (S$978,000) mark for a unit.

With 44 per cent of the large-scale housing estates, a market that has seen a stronger take-up than many single-block developments, Cheung Kong was singled out by Barclays as another developer best placed to win in this market.

On the flip side, Sino Land and Kerry Properties , which have 87 per cent and 82 per cent respectively of their saleable units in the mid-end and luxury sectors, are the most exposed among peers to buyers directly affected by government property curbs, according to data from Macquarie.


Prices for Hong Kong real estate have soared nearly 120 per cent since 2008 despite government efforts to cool the market and the city's property tycoons have taken a hit as buyers drive tougher bargains in one of the world's most expensive real estate markets.

Investors will be watching closely for the latest impact when Cheung Kong, controlled by billionaire Li Ka-Shing, and Sun Hung Kai report earnings on Friday.

On Wednesday, Hong Kong Finance Secretary John Tsang said the government would not loosen the property cooling measures that have forced developers to impose steep discounts to meet sales targets, weighing on profit margins.

With new home supply forecast to hit an eight-year high in 2014, competition to lure buyers will intensify, which could trigger even steeper discounts and further pressure margins.

Sun Hung Kai recently offered a longer payment period of up to 540 days for first-time buyers, a so-called "move in first and pay later" tactic that analysts said was rare.

The measure is designed to give people who want to upgrade more time to sell their old homes, without having to pay higher stamp duties - imposed in February last year - on their new ones, analysts say.

Hong Kong's middle class is waiting for developers to offer price cuts and more flexible payment options, said Mr Wong Leung Sing, research director at Centaline Property Agency.

"Sun Hung Kai is doing quite well, so other developers such as Cheung Kong and New World Development may follow similar sales tactics for their upcoming large-scale projects," said Mr Wong.


Sales have shown signs of a pick-up, thanks to mass-market demand and various incentives, although with a 10 per cent price drop forecast for this year and a surge in construction costs, some industry watchers said the good times may be over for the city's developers.

UBS estimates profit margins for Hong Kong's six major developers will fall from 36 per cent in 2012 to 20 per cent in 2015 and 14 per cent in 2016.

The price difference between new launches and second-hand homes - an indicator of developers' profitability - dropped to its lowest since 2005 at 0.2 per cent in the last quarter of 2013, according to real estate company Midland Realty.

Sun Hung Kai this month offered a 35 per cent discount on a project and made it 10 per cent below secondary homes in the same district, while Cheung Kong cut prices for a new launch by 28 per cent.

"Construction costs are up and they're not going to fall,"said Mr Ricky Poon, executive director of residential sales at real estate services firm Colliers International. "Unless they purchase land in the coming year for 20 per cent less, profit margins will drop. That's for sure."

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.