Hong Kong double killing: Jury warned they'll need to view torture video

Jutting, a former British banker, filmed a series of videos, including one showing the first killing. He also talked about his plans for the second victim in other videos.
Jutting, a former British banker, filmed a series of videos, including one showing the first killing. He also talked about his plans for the second victim in other videos. PHOTO: EUROPEAN PRESSPHOTO AGENCY

Judge issues caution during selection of jury; grisly task needed to decide degree of crime

HONG KONG • A Hong Kong judge warned jurors that they will have to view video filmed by former British banker Rurik Jutting of the torture and vicious killing of two Indonesian women he is accused of murdering as the trial got under way yesterday.

Jutting, who studied at Cambridge University and Winchester College, one of Britain's most prestigious private schools, pleaded not guilty to murder on grounds of "diminished responsibility". He was arrested two years ago after the victims' bodies were found in his luxury high-rise apartment.

The 31-year-old pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of manslaughter, and to a third charge of preventing lawful burial of a body.

During the jury selection, deputy High Court judge Michael Stuart-Moore warned potential jurors that if they were unable to cope with viewing extreme violence, they should not take part.

"There is a particularly horrifying aspect of the case. One of the victims was subject to extreme cruelty and violence," the judge said, explaining that a number of gruesome colour photographs could be presented during the trial.

  • Gory details

  • The lurid nature of former British banker Rurik Jutting's case has cast a harsh light on the seamy side of Hong Kong, offering an insight into how some wealthy professionals binge on sex, drugs and alcohol.

    According to the court fact sheet yesterday, Ms Sumarti Ningsih, one of Jutting's two victims, was tortured for three days using his fists, belt, sex toys and pliers. He eventually cut her throat with a serrated-edged knife in October 2014.

    After that, he made a video in which he talked about watching porn including episodes depicting violence. He also talked about whether to turn himself in or hide the body and fly to Britain.

    Six days later, he killed the second victim after luring her to his flat. He grabbed Ms Seneng Mujiasih and pulled her to the floor before he cut her throat with a knife, the prosecutor said yesterday.

    Investigators also found cocaine at his apartment, according to the fact sheet.

    "I definitely could not have done that without cocaine," it quoted Jutting as telling investigators during interviews. 



"The defendant even recorded on his iPhone the torture inflicted on the first victim before she died."

Jutting filmed a series of videos, including one showing the first killing, while in other videos he talks about his plans for the second, according to a court fact sheet.

The judge said the defence and prosecution were largely in agreement over the physical evidence, but the dispute may lie in psychiatric and psychological evidence provided by the defence to determine whether it was a case of murder or manslaughter.

Looking trim and dressed in a dark blue shirt, Jutting was clean-shaven with short hair, in stark contrast to his initial court appearances when he looked heavily overweight and had a thick dark beard.

Jutting who previously worked at Bank of America in Hong Kong, was accused of murder in October 2014, after police found the bodies of Sumarti Ningsih, 23, and Seneng Mujiasih, 26, in his apartment. Both women's throats were slit.

Ms Ningsih's remains were discovered in a suitcase on his balcony and the body of Ms Mujiasih was found lying inside the apartment with wounds to her neck and buttocks, the authorities said.

Before the jury selection, Jutting's barrister Tim Owen explained that the argument for diminished responsibility was based on the grounds of a personality disorder.

The judge said "there isn't a disease here, it is a personality disorder".

Prosecutor John Reading stated that psychopathic behaviour was not a reason for diminished responsibility, setting up the arguments both parties will make during the trial.

The jury has to decide if it is a case of murder or manslaughter.

They will today view 30 minutes of "highly graphic" video that will not be viewable for the public in the courtroom, though the sound will be audible.

The case is being closely watched by Hong Kong's 300,000-strong migrant domestic helper community, many from Indonesia and the Philippines. Outside the High Court, about a dozen of their representatives held placards reading "Justice for Wan Chai murder victim" and "Stop Violence".


A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on October 25, 2016, with the headline 'HK double killing: Jury warned they'll need to view torture video'. Print Edition | Subscribe