Pilot error could be cause of TransAsia crash, say analysts

Rescuers and divers search for missing passengers at the crash site of the Transasia ATR 72-600 turboprop plane in the Keelung river in New Taipei City on Feb 6, 2015. The blackbox data and voice recorders of a TransAsia plane that crashed into
Rescuers and divers search for missing passengers at the crash site of the Transasia ATR 72-600 turboprop plane in the Keelung river in New Taipei City on Feb 6, 2015. The blackbox data and voice recorders of a TransAsia plane that crashed into a river in Taipei showed that the pilot called "mayday" and announced an engine flameout 35 seconds after noticing engine failure, aviation authorities said on Friday. -- PHOTO: AFP

TAIPEI (AFP, Reuters) - One engine failed on the TransAsia Airways plane that crashed in Taiwan this week with the loss of at least 35 lives, and the pilots may have inexplicably shut down the other, investigators and experts said Friday.

Analysts say the initial findings from the plane's black boxes show it was probable the crew made an error.

The findings were released as reports emerged that the chief pilot was still clutching the joystick when his body was found in the cockpit, after he apparently battled to avoid populated areas.

The Civil Aeronautics Administration (CAA) also disclosed that TransAir Airways had failed to meet around a third of the regulatory requirements imposed after another fatal crash last July in Taiwan's western Penghu islands.

On Wednesday the French-made ATR 72-600 plane, equipped with two Pratt & Whitney turboprop engines, plummeted into a river after clipping an elevated road, as shown in dramatic dashcam footage.

In the first account of the last moments of Flight GE235, Taiwan's Aviation Safety Council said the right engine had "flamed out" about two minutes after takeoff from an airport in northern Taipei.

Warning signals blared in the cockpit and the left engine was then shut down manually by the crew, for unknown reasons, the council's director Thomas Wang told a news conference.

"The pilot tried to restart the engines but to no avail. That means that during the flight's final moments, neither engine had any thrust," he said. "We heard 'Mayday' at 10:54:35." Wang said it was "not clear" why the left engine was shut down manually. "We are not reaching any judgement yet," he said.

Analysts said it was probable the pilots made a mistake. "It looks like they shut the wrong engine," said Greg Waldron, the Singapore-based Asia managing editor at aviation industry publication Flightglobal.

"The right-side engine flamed out but that in itself is not enough to cause a crash because the ATR is designed to fly on one engine," he noted. "What happened was that a few seconds after engine two flamed out, they (the pilots) cut the fuel to engine one, and when they cut fuel to engine one that's when things started to go haywire because the plane was not powered anymore."

Such a hypothesis recalls the 1989 crash of a British Midland Boeing 737-400, which came down on a motorway in central England when the pilots shut down a functioning engine instead of a defective one. Forty-seven people were killed.

Gerry Soejatman, a Jakarta-based independent aviation analyst, said the Taiwan incident "could have been an innocent mistake". "I will have to take a look again but changes in the layout of the engine instrumentation of the aircraft (compared with an older version of the ATR 72) could be a factor," he said.


Taiwan authorities said that the year-old plane had also developed a problem with an engine during its delivery flight from manufacturer ATR, from the French city of Toulouse to Macau, en route to Taiwan.

The TransAsia plane crashed shortly after take-off on a domestic flight to an outlying island. The startling footage showed it hitting the road as it banked steeply away from buildings and into the Keelung River.

Pilot Liao Chien-tsung has been hailed as a hero for apparently making a desperate attempt to steer the plane, with 53 passengers and five crew on board, away from built-up areas during its steep descent. His body was found in the cockpit still holding the joystick with both hands, and with his legs badly fractured, according to the China Times.

"He disregarded his own life. He sacrificed it," Liao's sobbing mother told reporters.

Vice-President Wu Den-yih also praised Liao as he visited a funeral parlour where crash victims were taken. "The pilot gripped the joystick tightly and was trying to control the airplane right up to the very last moment so as to avoid hitting city residents," Wu said.

The plane took off from Taipei's downtown Songshan airport and was bound for the Taiwan island of Kinmen. Among those on board were 31 tourists from China, mainly from the southwestern city of Xiamen.

Fifteen people survived the crash, and hundreds of rescuers and divers are battling bad weather to search for those still missing, with four more bodies retrieved from the the chilly waters on Friday.

The CAA has grounded a total of 22 ATR planes from TransAsia and Uni Air, a subsidiary of EVA Airways Corp, for safety checks following the accident, and TransAsia has been banned from applying for new routes for one year.

Wednesday's incident came just seven months after another TransAsia ATR crashed during a storm, killing 48 people. Calls are mounting from lawmakers for a total suspension of the privately-owned airline's operations.

Clark Lin, chief of the CAA's Flight Standard Division, said the airline had failed to meet many of the requirements laid down by the regulator after the July crash.

"As of the end of December, the company has failed to match around one-third of the requirements that demanded the company to improve, especially on flight safety as well personnel training and performance review," he said, ahead of a deadline set for June.

The crash was the latest in a string of Asian air disasters. Indonesia has expanded its search for bodies of AirAsia Flight QZ8501 that crashed into the Java Sea in December, killing all 162 people on board.

After a lull in search and recovery efforts, more bodies and wreckage were found in the past few days off the coast of the Indonesian island of Sulawesi. A total of 96 bodies have been found.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.