More hardline measures to come from Hong Kong government, not Beijing, say experts

A People's Liberation Army soldier holding up a yellow placard to warn anti-government protesters during a demonstration on Sunday. Protesters had gathered at the PLA barracks in Hong Kong and shone laser pointers at troops. PHOTO: REUTERS

The approach towards the protests that have gripped Hong Kong for over four months will get more hardline, but these would involve measures taken by the Hong Kong government, not Beijing, said experts.

They believe that the deployment of People's Liberation Army (PLA) troops or the People's Armed Police, a paramilitary force, to quell the unrest remains a remote possibility despite the provocation by protesters on Sunday.

A few hundred protesters gathered at the PLA barracks in the city on Sunday night and shone laser pointers at troops, which led to the first direct interaction between them.

The Chinese soldiers turned on a number of spotlights at the protesters and monitored them with binoculars and cameras while warning them that they were breaking the law and could be prosecuted. The protesters eventually dispersed.

Deputy dean of Tsinghua University's School of Social Sciences Zhao Kejin said despite the provocations by protesters, it was not going to change the central government's "very clear" policy on Hong Kong.

"Hong Kong's issues will be dealt with by the Special Administrative Region's government and the Hong Kong police force. Unless foreign military forces interfere, the PLA garrison will not take part in Hong Kong's internal matters. These will be handled by the police," said Professor Zhao.

Under Hong Kong's Basic Law, soldiers from the mainland are allowed to be stationed in the city for defence. It also allows the Hong Kong government to ask Beijing to deploy troops to assist in maintaining public order.

Hong Kong experienced yet another weekend of violence, as thousands took to the streets in defiance of a ban on using face masks at public assemblies. The city's government had, on Friday, resorted to colonial-era emergency legislation to impose the ban. The move, which came just days after China celebrated its National Day, garnered strong support on the mainland.

Remote video URL

"The masked protesters use violence to destroy public property. This is not freedom of expression, this is illegal and violent," said Prof Zhao.

Professor Lau Siu Kai, vice-president of the Chinese Association of Hong Kong and Macau Studies, a semi-official advisory body set up by Beijing, said the anti-mask legislation "may be the beginning of a process of introducing more stringent measures".

Hong Kong's Emergency Regulations Ordinance, which was last used in deadly riots in the 1960s, gives the city's chief executive power to enact rules without going through the legislature.

Outlining some of the measures the government could take, Prof Lau said the law also allowed it to shut media outlets that advocate violence.

It could also lengthen the amount of time that police can detain suspects, beyond the 48 hours that they currently are allowed to, before charging them with a criminal offence or releasing them.

Another option that is reportedly on the cards is a curfew.

The police could also use more live ammunition, he said. Already, two protesters have been shot by the police over the past week.

Prof Lau added that while these measures might trigger more protests initially, the city's government believed it would help quell the unrest over time.

"The situation might be getting more violent and Beijing is getting more and more impatient, but still Beijing will depend on the Hong Kong government," he said.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on October 08, 2019, with the headline More hardline measures to come from Hong Kong government, not Beijing, say experts. Subscribe