Japan's Covid-19 crisis reawakens deflation fears as cash hoarding returns

High-frequency data shows consumption began to falter even before January's state of emergency. PHOTO: AFP

TOKYO (REUTERS) - A spike in coronavirus infections in Japan is driving local households to do what they have always done in times of crisis: Spend less and save more, stoking fears of a deeper retail recession and grinding deflation.

Fifty-year-old Hiromi Suzuki is doing just that, having quit her job at a Tokyo novelty store in December after the pandemic hit sales.

"I try not to spend money," she said, walking her dog in the city.

"Since I don't go out much, I don't buy cosmetics or clothes any more."

Ms Suzuki's case exemplifies the trouble Japan faces as Covid-19 state of emergency measures were reinstated in January, hitting spending on services, which makes up one-third of total consumption.

High-frequency data shows consumption began to falter even before January's state of emergency, catching policymakers off guard and forcing both the government and central bank to cut their assessments on private spending.

"Service spending is slumping sharply," Bank of Japan Governor Haruhiko Kuroda said last week.

"We don't expect Japan to return to deflation. But we need to keep vigilant on price moves given very high uncertainty over the outlook."

While demand for some goods is holding up, analysts warn it won't be strong enough to offset deflationary pressures caused by weak service spending.

"The economy will be in bad shape in the first quarter, which would push prices down," said Mr Hiroshi Ugai, chief Japan economist at JPMorgan Securities.

"Prices will essentially remain weak this year."

Despite a rebound after initial lockdown measures were lifted in May, consumption later lost momentum, falling more than 4 per cent in November from January's pre-pandemic levels, according to a BOJ gauge of spending.

That was mostly due to a 10 per cent slump in services spending, which contrasted with an 8 per cent gain in durable goods consumption.

The pain continued in December with consumption falling 11.5 per cent from a year ago, mainly due to a 20 per cent drop in services spending, according to research firm Nowcast and credit card company JCB.

Spending on eating out fell 36 per cent, while dining at "izakaya" bars slumped 47 per cent, both marking the biggest declines since May.


A government request for restaurants to close early means retailers are now feeling the pinch.

Monteroza, which runs several popular pub chains, said it was closing 61 of its 337 locations in Tokyo.

Meanwhile, beverage giant Suntory Holdings CEO Takeshi Niinami predicts that 30 per cent of all bars and restaurants might fail in the coming months.

The average number of customers per restaurant fell 60 per cent in January from a year ago, data by booking site TableCheck showed, faster than a 23 per cent slide in November and a 40 per cent drop in December.

Japanese households are not spending much on other items either.

A BOJ survey showed more than 70 per cent of households don't plan to change the amount spent to enjoy time at home.

Instead, they are hoarding cash in banks, as they have done through every crisis including the two decades of debilitating deflation that haunted Japan until 2013.

Bank deposits surged 9.3 per cent in December from a year earlier to a record 803 trillion yen (S$10.26 trillion).

Households are expected to have saved 45.8 trillion yen, or 8.5 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP), last year, up from 14.5 trillion in 2019, estimates by HSBC showed.

"Unless fears over the pandemic are wiped out, the money piling up in bank accounts won't be spent," said Mr Toshihiro Nagahama, chief economist at Dai-ichi Life Research Institute.

The BOJ has downplayed concerns about a return to deflation, arguing that companies aren't cutting prices across the board, as doing so would eat already thin margins.

Nonetheless, core consumer prices fell 1.0 per cent in December from a year earlier, marking the biggest drop in a decade, a sign weak demand is heightening deflationary pressures.

Even fashion group Fast Retailing Co Ltd, seen as resilient due to brisk demand for its casual at-home attire, plans to lower prices of discount brand GU's spring and summer collections.

While Fast Retailing is wary of cutting prices at its main Uniqlo brand, discounts are planned in coming months to reduce inventory, CFO Takeshi Okazaki said earlier this month.

The hope is that more households will act like Ms Noriko Indo, an 81-year-old pensioner who keeps a tight rein on spending but occasionally indulges in luxuries like tuna sashimi, her favourite food.

"Once the pandemic is over, I'd like to splurge on travel and shop like crazy at a department store," she said.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.