China builds village on land Bhutan regards as its own

Beijing's move follows similar constructions in contested areas of South China Sea

Satellite images from last December (left) and from October (below) showing China's construction of a village in territory also claimed by Bhutan. PHOTOS: SCREENGRAB/ MAXAR TECHNOLOGIES
Satellite images from last December and from October (above) showing China's construction of a village in territory also claimed by Bhutan. PHOTOS: SCREENGRAB/ MAXAR TECHNOLOGIES
Satellite images from last December (left) and from October (below) showing China's construction of a village in territory also claimed by Bhutan. PHOTOS: SCREENGRAB/ MAXAR TECHNOLOGIES
Satellite images from last December (above) and from October showing China's construction of a village in territory also claimed by Bhutan. PHOTOS: SCREENGRAB/ MAXAR TECHNOLOGIES

BEIJING • Just in time for its National Day in October, China completed construction of a new village high in the mountains where the Chinese region of Tibet meets the kingdom of Bhutan.

A hundred people moved into two dozen new homes beside the Torsa River and celebrated the holiday by raising China's flag and singing the national anthem.

"Each of us is a coordinate of the great motherland," a border guard was quoted as saying by state news agency, China Tibetan News.

The problem is, these new "coordinates" are more than 1.6km inside what Bhutan considers to be its territory.

The construction, documented in satellite photos, followed a playbook that China has used for years. It has brushed aside neighbours' claims of sovereignty to cement its position in territorial disputes by unilaterally changing the facts on the ground.

It used similar tactics in the South China Sea, where it fortified and armed shoals claimed by Vietnam and the Philippines, despite promising the United States not to do so.

This year, China's military built up forces in the Himalayas and crossed into territory that India claimed was on its side of the two countries' de facto border.

That led to China's bloodiest clash in decades, leaving at least 21 Indian soldiers dead, along with an unknown number of Chinese troops.

The violence badly soured bilateral relations that had been steadily improving.

Even when challenged, China's territorial grabs are difficult to reverse, short of the use of force, as the Indian government has learnt. Since the dispute at the border, Chinese troops have remained camped in areas that India once controlled.

"In the end, it reflects the consolidation of China's control over the area it claims," said an expert on China's military, Associate Professor M. Taylor Fravel.

Over the past year, China has moved against many of its neighbours, seemingly with little regard for the possible fallout. President Xi Jinping often cites China's historical grievances against foreign encroachment and colonisation, using its past to justify its strategic activities.

The construction of the Himalayan village suggests that China has extended a broader campaign to fortify its southern flanks to include Bhutan, a nation of 800,000 people.

As the construction was under way on that long-disputed border, China added a new claim this summer to nearly 780 sq km of territory in the Sakteng Wildlife Sanctuary, an area on the other side of Bhutan from where the village was being built.

In pushing its boundaries, China appears to have brushed aside decades of quiet and ultimately fruitless talks to finalise the two countries' border. A 25th round of talks this year was postponed because of the coronavirus.

"The Chinese obviously seem to be losing patience," Mr Tenzing Lamsang, editor of the newspaper The Bhutanese and president of the Media Association of Bhutan, wrote on Twitter.

The dispute stems from different interpretations of a treaty signed in 1890 by two now-defunct imperial powers, Britain as India's colonial ruler and the Qing dynasty.

The new village is near the Doklam plateau, where the borders of China, India and Bhutan converge. The plateau was the site of a 73-day stand-off between Indian and Chinese troops in 2017 that began over the construction of a road into Bhutanese territory. India, which is obliged to defend Bhutan under a longstanding security pact, sent troops to halt the Chinese work.

Bhutan, which in recent years has felt squeezed between the two giants, poses no military threat to China.

For China, control of the area would give its forces a strategic position near a narrow strip of land in India, the Siliguri Corridor.

That area, which Indian military strategists call the Chicken Neck, connects the bulk of India to its eastern-most provinces bordering Bangladesh, Myanmar and China.

Mr Lamsang noted that Bhutan has long had to defer to India's security interests.

In its repeated talks with the Chinese, Bhutan has so far been unwilling to make any territorial concessions along the western and central borders.

Neither the Bhutanese nor the Chinese foreign ministry responded to requests for comment.

The Global Times, a Communist Party newspaper, ridiculed the claims that the newly built village was in Bhutan, blaming India for stoking tensions with China's southern neighbours.

It later warned against "looming foreign forces backing the China-bashing campaign across the Himalayas".

The exact location of the new village, called Pangda, emerged in a series of satellite images published recently by US-based Maxar Technologies.

The images showed that construction began late last year and was completed, it seems, not long before Oct 1 - China's National Day.

China's version of the border lies south of the village.

The images also showed extensive new road-building and the construction of what seem to be military storage bunkers, said Maxar spokesman Stephen Wood.

The bunkers are in undisputed Chinese territory, though, indicating that China has sought to build up its military presence along much of the Himalayan border area.

NYTIMES

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Sunday Times on November 29, 2020, with the headline China builds village on land Bhutan regards as its own. Subscribe