Reactions to Duterte's remarks on 'separating' from the US - In China

Beijing under no illusion Manila will pivot away from Washington after Rodrigo Duterte remarks

Mr Duterte at a meeting with top legislator Zhang Dejiang at Beijing's Great Hall of the People on Thursday. China is aware that he does not decide on his country's foreign policy on his own, said Chinese analysts.
Mr Duterte at a meeting with top legislator Zhang Dejiang at Beijing's Great Hall of the People on Thursday. China is aware that he does not decide on his country's foreign policy on his own, said Chinese analysts.PHOTO: AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE

Media and officials silent on Duterte's effusive praise and his remarks on US

While Beijing has laid out the red carpet for Mr Rodrigo Duterte this week, and returned the embrace of the Philippine President, it is under no illusion that Manila will pivot away from Washington.

China may stand to gain if Mr Duterte breaks away from the US in geopolitical terms, as he said he would on Thursday. But it is fully aware that he does not decide on the Philippines' foreign policy on his own and will have to go through the political processes domestically, Chinese analysts have said.

During his four-day stay in Beijing, Mr Duterte took every opportunity to assert his anti-West stance, especially towards the US.

The 71-year-old leader went as far as to proclaim his "separation from the United States" in both military and economic terms at a business forum in Beijing on Thursday. He showered praise on the country and its people, and announced that "Duterte of the Philippines is veering towards China because China has the character of an Oriental. It does not go around insulting people".

While Beijing laid out full honours for Mr Duterte, in a reception seldom accorded to regional leaders, Chinese media and officials have been silent on his effusive praise of the Chinese and his declaration of separation from the US.


Chinese netizens, displaying some scepticism, said he was making these remarks to extract benefits from China, such as soft loans.

Some likened his "separation" from the US to a new social phenomenon in China in which people make use of fake divorces to get round restrictive regulations in order to obtain a second housing loan.

Dr Li Kaisheng from the Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences noted that while Mr Duterte wishes to separate from the US, what it really means is unclear. "This is not the first time Mr Duterte has said this, and it merely represents what he really feels." But it is hard to say if this will be translated into actual policies, he said.

"On the one hand, it may be good for Beijing given that the US has been using the Philippines to contain China in the region," said Dr Li.

On the flip side, if Mr Duterte gets toppled as a result of soured US-Philippine ties, Beijing may stand to lose even more given that Sino-Philippine relations are only starting to improve, he added.

Noting that there had been no reaction from Chinese officials so far to Mr Duterte's remarks, he said he did not expect them to respond.

Beijing-based analyst Zha Wen said China does not expect Manila to break its long-time alliance with Washington. "We should not take a zero-sum view on these relationships," said Dr Zha from China Foreign Affairs University.

What Beijing wants is for bilateral relations to improve and for Manila to conduct a more balanced foreign policy, she added.

Agreeing, Dr Li said the agreements and loans signed should not be viewed as carrots to support Manila's break from Washington.

Beijing has responded to Mr Duterte's friendly overtures with a lavish welcome that shows a high level of goodwill and respect.

Notably, he was given access to four of the seven members of the powerful Politburo Standing Committee: President Xi Jinping, Premier Li Keqiang, top legislator Zhang Dejiang and top-ranking Vice-Premier Zhang Gaoli. In return, Beijing has achieved its goal of diffusing tensions in the South China Sea by reaching an agreement with Manila to resume bilateral talks on their territorial disputes.

This could signal to other countries that in handling conflicts with China, it is best to put aside disputes and focus on cooperation, said Dr Xu Liping, an Asean researcher with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. "It is unrealistic to expect China to compromise, and as a big country, it has the ability to give you a lot of benefits," he added.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on October 22, 2016, with the headline 'Beijing under no illusion Manila will pivot away from Washington'. Print Edition | Subscribe