Aussies urged not to build homes in high-risk areas

Report on devastating bush fires highlights climate change threats

An inquiry into Australia's bush fire crisis (above) late last year and early this year warns that climate-worsened disasters will become more frequent, more costly and more severe.
An inquiry into Australia's bush fire crisis (above) late last year and early this year warns that climate-worsened disasters will become more frequent, more costly and more severe. PHOTO: AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE

A long-awaited report into Australia's devastating bush fires last summer has provided an ominous insight into a post-global warming future and raised questions about where Australians should live and the types of homes they live in.

A Royal Commission inquiry into the fires that began late last year and stretched into this year found that climate change was leading to more intense and catastrophic natural disasters.

"The summer of 2019-2020 - in which some communities experienced drought, heatwaves, bush fires, hailstorms, and flooding - provided only a glimpse of the types of events that Australia may face in the future," the report said.

"Natural disasters are expected to become more complex, more unpredictable, and more difficult to manage."

The commission highlighted the need for Australia to consider how and where to build homes, businesses and infrastructure.

It heard evidence that more than 380,000 properties are in high risk natural disaster areas - a statistic that is not surprising given that even some densely-populated suburbs of Sydney and Melbourne are surrounded by forests that regularly experience fires.

But the commission also heard that the growing threat from more extreme disasters such as fires and flooding meant that 735,000 properties would be in high risk areas by 2100, even if no new homes were built.

"How towns and cities are planned and the manner in which homes and infrastructure are built have long lasting ramifications," the report said. "These decisions influence the exposure and vulnerability of communities and assets."

Bush fires are a regular occurrence in Australia, where vast swathes of territory are covered by thick dense bush land that can turn into a tinderbox in dry weather.

The 2019-2020 fires killed 33 people across the country and destroyed more than 3,100 properties. The Insurance Council of Australia has said that 99 per cent of buildings destroyed were within 500m of bush land.

In addition, the fires razed more than 24 million ha of land, producing smoke that contributed to hundreds of further deaths due to cardiovascular and respiratory effects. Almost three billion animals were also killed or displaced, threatening native species and causing long-term ecological consequences. The total estimated cost of the fires was more than A$10 billion (S$9.79 billion).

The Royal Commission, chaired by a former chief of the defence force, Retired Air Chief Marshal Mark Binskin, recommended that the state and federal authorities consider introducing a nationwide procedure for informing residents and potential home buyers about the risks of individual properties.

In addition, the commission said state governments and local councils should be required to consider the disaster risk in specific areas when deciding whether to allow construction of new buildings.

"Development in high-risk areas should be avoided unless risk can be clearly communicated and cost-effectively managed," the report said.

  • 33

    Number of people who died across Australia due to the bush fires.


    More than this number of properties were destroyed during the fires.


    Estimated cost of the blazes.

The commission also heard that some 90 per cent of buildings in areas prone to bush fires do not satisfy current building safety requirements because they were constructed before the latest standards were introduced. But upgrading all properties in Australia would cost billions of dollars.

The commission recommended that state governments and local councils consider providing subsidies to home owners to encourage them to upgrade homes or reduce the risk to their properties.

Responding to the commission's 80 recommendations, Federal Minister for Emergency Management David Littleproud committed to "actioning many of the recommendations as soon as possible".

"The Royal Commission report outlines lessons for us all on how to better prepare for, manage and recover from natural disasters," he said in a statement.

"There are lessons for governments, essential service providers, insurers, charities, communities and individuals."

Significantly, the commission noted the effects of climate change, saying that further warming over the next 20 to 30 years was inevitable. It did not make specific recommendations about emission targets, but observed: "Catastrophic fire conditions may render traditional bush fire prediction models and firefighting techniques less effective."

The ruling Liberal-National coalition has been reluctant to impose strict carbon emission reduction measures or embrace ambitious green energy targets.

Discussing the commission's report, an expert on fire science, Professor David Bowman of the University of Tasmania, called for public monitoring of the implementation of its recommendations.

"Fundamentally, political appetite will determine whether the royal commission's recommendations ever become reality," Prof Bowman wrote on The Conversation website. "There is much work to be done by governments and others… And the Morrison government has given next to no indication it's willing to seriously tackle the problem of climate change."

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on November 09, 2020, with the headline Aussies urged not to build homes in high-risk areas. Subscribe