Ardern's election mandate may be thwarted by Covid-19

Jacinda Ardern's critics have questioned her ability to tackle the economic crisis.
Jacinda Ardern's critics have questioned her ability to tackle the economic crisis.PHOTO: AFP

WELLINGTON • Ms Jacinda Ardern's landslide election win gives her a mandate for the transformational change she has been promising New Zealand for three years, but the Covid-19 pandemic may limit what she can do.

The Prime Minister's signature achievement in all but eliminating the coronavirus from the Pacific island nation through strict lockdowns propelled her to victory last Saturday.

But this approach may also hinder the recovery New Zealanders are hoping for and the progressive policies championed by Ms Ardern.

The general election was "tectonic" and with this mandate, Ms Ardern "needs to deliver", said professor of politics Richard Shaw of Massey University.

Early yesterday, hours after delivering the biggest win in half a century for her centre-left Labour Party, Ms Ardern was dealing with the pandemic again as a new infection sprang up, ending a two-week coronavirus-free run.

New Zealand had been free of community cases for more than 100 days until new infections emerged in Auckland in August.

The new case is unlikely to spread further, health officials said, but it highlighted the risk the nation of five million faces as it pours its efforts into keeping the raging pandemic off its shores.

Ms Ardern has assigned NZ$62 billion (S$55.7 billion) to Covid-19 recovery this year, most of it on wage subsidies to avoid massive job losses.

She deployed business loans and rent freezes, and eased some tax requirements. But with no plans for major tax reform and revenue shrinking from tourism and immigration, two of New Zealand's top money generators, there are questions over how the government can achieve its social and economic goals.

"There is not a huge pot of money available outside of the Covid response," said Mr Brad Olsen, senior economist at Wellington-based economic consultancy firm Infometrics.

"So you do wonder what issues have to take priority and how they can achieve transformational change while also ramping up the Covid-19 response."

With net core crown debt forecast at NZ$201 billion, or 55 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) by 2024 - up from less than 20 per cent before the pandemic - Ms Ardern's borrowing options are shrinking. New Zealand governments of all stripes have traditionally sought to keep debt below 20 per cent of GDP.

Ms Ardern, 40, trailing in opinion polls as late as February, saw Labour's support shoot up as New Zealanders rallied behind her "go hard, go early" approach to Covid-19.

But her strict lockdowns crippled the tourism-centred economy and hobbled her efforts to tackle child poverty, homelessness, inequality and climate change. Unemployment is expected to double to about 8 per cent in the next two years.

Voters do not want the government to cut spending, Mr Olsen said.

Ms Ardern wants to build affordable housing, raise minimum wages and spur thousands of jobs in environment-friendly projects.

On issues like child poverty and homelessness, where New Zealand is one of the worst performers among developed nations, Ms Ardern has launched schemes like free school lunches and support for buying first homes.

She had argued that it was impossible to meet these targets in her first three-year term, asking voters for a full mandate to bring meaningful change.

"After this result, we have the mandate to accelerate our response and our recovery, and tomorrow we start," she promised voters on Saturday night.

Ms Ardern's critics, however, have questioned her ability to tackle the economic crisis.

"I feel very concerned for my country," opposition National Party leader Judith Collins said yesterday, vowing to keep pressing Ms Ardern on economic issues.

Ms Collins had argued that the centre-right National was better placed to take New Zealand through this financial crisis.

Ms Ardern's biggest success has been to draw New Zealanders closer with her brand of compassionate leadership at a time of deep uncertainty, in contrast to other political leaders around the world who were seen as polarising and dividing.

She struck a similar tone with supporters after the vote, saying that in an increasingly polarised world, New Zealand was showing it was united.

"Elections aren't always great at bringing people together, but they also don't need to tear one another apart," she said.


A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on October 19, 2020, with the headline 'Ardern's election mandate may be thwarted by Covid-19'. Print Edition | Subscribe