Tackling disinformation: EU offers guide

Report calls for more transparency of online platforms, warns against simplistic solutions

SPH Brightcove Video
For many, fact-checking and truth come second, based on a report by the Institute of Policy Studies. The exchange underscores a major theme that emerged during the first public hearing on deliberate online falsehoods on Wednesday (March 14).
The report written by a panel of 39 experts appointed by the European Commission called for online platforms to be more transparent and for media literacy to be promoted, while warning against any simplistic solutions to the problems of disinformation. PHOTO: REUTERS

While tackling the scourge of disinformation, governments and other parties should avoid interfering with freedom of expression and media freedom, said a report published yesterday by the European Union's executive arm.

The report called for online platforms to be more transparent and for media literacy to be promoted, while warning against any simplistic solutions to the problems of disinformation.

It also made a plea for more tools to empower users and journalists to tackle disinformation, and for the diversity and sustainability of news media to be safeguarded.

It found these measures to be particularly critical ahead of elections.

The report was written by a panel of 39 experts appointed by the European Commission. They came from civil society, social media platforms, journalism and academia.

The experts focused on disinformation rather than "fake news", a term they said is "used misleadingly by powerful actors to dismiss coverage that is simply found disagreeable".

Disinformation was defined as "all forms of false, inaccurate or misleading information designed, presented and promoted to intentionally cause public harm or for profit".

Also published were the results of a Eurobarometer survey of 26,000 citizens, which found that people think that there is a lot of fake news across the EU.

Most respondents - 83 per cent - said the phenomenon represents a danger to democracy, while many also saw traditional media as the most trustworthy source of news.

Radio news sources got a "trust rate" of 73 per cent, followed by television at 66 per cent, and print at 63 per cent. Online sources got the lowest rating of 26 per cent.

"While not necessarily illegal, disinformation can nonetheless be harmful for citizens and society at large," the report said.

It said the dangers represented threats to democratic political processes, including the integrity of elections, and to democratic values that shape public policy across sectors as diverse as health, science and finance.

The report stressed that special attention should be paid to disinformation aimed at undermining the integrity of elections.

People require accurate information to vote, but elections are also vulnerable to digital disinformation campaigns, it said.

These can include rumours about rigging and hacking of voting machines, and purchases and non-transparent dissemination of political advertisements which may influence voters and cast general suspicion over the democratic process.

Equally important is the threat of "more insidious and low-profile disinformation strategies not linked to any political event", said the report.

Such campaigns can distort citizens' perceptions of events and give rise to deep-seated misinformed beliefs, causing significant harm.

The panel called on online platforms to ensure transparency by explaining how algorithms select news that is put forward.

It also urged these platforms to make reliable, trustworthy news more visible, and to help users better access such news.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on March 13, 2018, with the headline Tackling disinformation: EU offers guide. Subscribe