Getting help when neighbours lock horns

Madam Lina's family and Madam Tan (above) went to the Community Mediation Centre in February over claims of noise disturbances. When the noises resumed, Madam Lina's family confronted Madam Tan, filmed the encounter and put it on Facebook. The CMC ha
Madam Lina's family and Madam Tan (above) went to the Community Mediation Centre in February over claims of noise disturbances. When the noises resumed, Madam Lina's family confronted Madam Tan, filmed the encounter and put it on Facebook. The CMC handled about 320 cases of neighbour disputes last year.PHOTO: NIKKI SHALS/FACEBOOK

More turning to the authorities to resolve disputes, HDB poll shows

IN THE wee hours of the morning, loud bangs sometimes shake the rental flat where freelance casting agent Madam Lina, 39, lives with her three children.

They believe the sounds are made by their downstairs neighbour.

"This is really stressful when you need peace and quiet at home," said Madam Lina, who works from home.

The neighbour, who goes by the name of Madam Tan, said Madam Lina's family is noisy too. And she denied making any noise.

The long-running saga has not seen any resolution despite calls to the police and visits to the Community Mediation Centre (CMC).

Their case is part of a larger trend: More residents are referring disputes to the authorities, and fewer confront neighbours directly, according to a Housing Board survey, which is conducted every five years.

In 2013, three in 10 residents faced nuisances from their neighbours, such as noise or littering, but took no action.

A further 9.4 per cent faced issues and went to the authorities, up from 7.4 per cent in 2008.

A smaller proportion resolved issues directly with their neighbours. In 2013, 9.1 per cent did so, down from 12 per cent before.

The HDB and Members of Parliament are some of the authorities residents turn to.

But neighbours should also try to talk to each other, said MPs. "When there's no talking, the resentment builds up," said Tampines MP Baey Yam Keng.

The HDB usually advises neighbours to resolve disputes among themselves, and will request grassroots leaders' help to mediate if needed, said an HDB spokesman.

"In most cases, residents are cooperative." But if the issue persists, the HDB will advise them to go to the CMC.

Neighbour disputes formed 56 per cent of the 571 cases handled by the CMC last year, or about 320 cases. This is up slightly from 294 cases in 2013, but still lower than the 400 cases in 2009.

The most common issues are noise, common corridor obstruction and verbal quarrels.

Said the CMC: "These are issues which arise from living in a community.

"It is therefore important to try and resolve the dispute in a manner that preserves neighbourly relations."

One reason for the persistent conflicts could be due to fewer residents knowing their neighbours in the first place, said Singapore Kindness Movement general secretary William Wan.

"When an issue arises, they think 'I never really knew you, so there's no point talking to you.' It's a problem. You really must try to talk and connect with each other first," he said.

But for tougher cases, Pasir Ris-Punggol MP Gan Thiam Poh hopes the Community Disputes Resolution Tribunal - which will be ready in the second half of this year - can help.

Unlike voluntary community mediation, the tribunal can order mandatory mediation and issue orders for parties to stop the disturbance or pay damages.

The CMC was where Madam Lina's family and Madam Tan, a 50-year-old unemployed woman, went to in February.

Though they came to an agreement then, the noises resumed in March, said Madam Lina.

The family turned to social media. On April 21, eldest daughter Shalina, 20, uploaded to Facebook a video of the noise and a confrontation with Madam Tan.

"I was hoping that people she knows might see it and tell her to stop knocking," said Ms Shalina, who works in customer service.

janiceh@sph.com.sg

yeosamjo@sph.com.sg