US top court strikes down abortion clinic buffer zone
Published on Jun 27, 2014 7:19 AM
WASHINGTON (AFP) - Buffer zones around abortion clinics in the state of Massachusetts were deemed unconstitutional Thursday by the US Supreme Court on grounds that they limit freedom of expression.
The Massachusetts law struck down by the high court had required protesters to stay at least 35 feet (10 metres) from the entrances to clinics that provide abortions. Thursday's ruling could have implications for other US states that have similar "buffer" legislation.
The high court ruled unanimously that the 2007 Massachusetts restriction violates the First Amendment of the US Constitution, which ensures freedom of expression.
The law, the court said in a decision written by Chief Justice John Roberts, "restricts access to 'public way[S]' and 'sidewalk[S],' places that have traditionally been open for speech activities." The decision acknowledged that the buffer zones had served Massachusetts' "legitimate interests in maintaining public safety on streets and sidewalks." But at the same time, it said, "they impose serious burdens on petitioners' speech, depriving them of their two primary methods of communicating with arriving patients: close, personal conversations and distribution of literature." Seven anti-abortion advocates led by plaintiff Eleanor McCullen appealed the case to the Supreme Court.
To continue reading, log in if you are a subscriber
If you are not a subscriber, you can get instant, unlimited access here