Porsche purists slam expansion drive
Sports-car maker's push into SUV and saloon markets undermines its racing roots, they say
Published on Aug 3, 2012 4:57 PM
Berlin - Mr Manfred Wilke loves nothing more than speeding down the German Autobahn in his 911 coupe.
Gazing at a 911 Carrera GTS with a €100,000 (S$165,000) price tag in Porsche's flagship showroom in Berlin, the real estate manager said only cars like the sporting two-seater deserved to carry the Porsche badge. He is one of a number of Porsche purists who are appalled at the Stuttgart-based sports-car maker's aggressive push into sport-utility vehicles (SUV) and family-style saloons.
Nearly 50 years after the launch of the 911, its newer, more roomy siblings, the Cayenne SUV and four-door Panamera, account for almost three-quarters of Porsche's sales, and some customers fear the company is straying too far from its racing roots.
'Only delusional marketers could attempt to turn Porsche into an offroader company,' said Mr Wilke, 53. 'It's a flat-out insult to Porsche's image and fame.'
The powerful 911, driven by Steve McQueen at the start of the 1971 movie Le Mans, has captivated fans for decades and came fifth in the 1999 Car of the Century awards. Its timeless design, refreshed again last year, evolved from the Porsche 356 designed by Ferry Porsche in 1948, the sports-car maker's first vehicle in series production.
But for now, the bulky four-door cars are king, as demand for large luxury models is growing faster than the sports- car market. Porsche's next major new model is a compact SUV called the Macan, which goes into production next year.
'Even at Porsche, SUVs promise stronger growth than the classical two- door sports cars,' said Mr Willi Diez, head of the Institute for Automobile Industry in Nuertingen. 'The Cayenne, Macan and Panamera have become the profit-laden springboard needed to develop the core Porsche stuff.'
He and others see Porsche becoming a two-brand company with the 911 and its other sports cars sitting alongside a portfolio of top-end luxury models.
Other marques such as Ferrari and Lamborghini have kept largely to sports cars, leaving their parents Fiat and Volkswagen to develop other types of cars.
Turning its focus from one of the world's most recognisable sports cars to the bulky Cayenne was not a natural progression, but a necessity if Porsche was to hit its targets.
Bolstered by its alliance with Europe's biggest carmaker Volkswagen, Porsche aims to sell 200,000 cars a year by 2018, up from 116,978 last year. It wants to keep its return on sales above 15 per cent after achieving 18.7 per cent last year.
Sales of the Cayenne, which saves costs by sharing a platform with VW's Touareg and Audi's Q7 SUV models, are expected to surge by 40 per cent in major car markets to 52,076 vehicles by 2017 from 2010, research firm IHS Automotive predicts.
The Macan should hit almost 37,000 in its first five years and sales of the Panamera could jump by 67 per cent to 33,643. Porsche sold 17,607 911s last year and IHS expects a slower growth rate in the next five years of about 37 per cent.
Porsche is spending €500 million to expand its factory in the eastern German city of Leipzig, adding body and paint shops and a new assembly line to produce the Macan. It also increased production of the Cayenne and the Panamera in January.
But its efforts to meet demand for upscale 4x4s has cost it the top spot in terms of its cars' perceived sporting image, according to a survey of 4,000 consumers by Germany's Adac automobile club, Europe's largest.
'There seems to be a greater emphasis at Porsche on short-term sales gains at the expense of the famous brand's image,' said Adac analyst Marcus Krueger.
But others said the overall Porsche brand was benefiting from the broader product range and the onus was on Porsche to keep the 911 at the top of its game.
'Porsche still stands for luxury and performance. But it is also important that flagship brands such as the 911 continue to convince through innovation,' said Mr Cassidy Morgan, head of Central and Eastern Europe at brand consultancy Interbrand.
Porsche, which achieves high ratings in quality studies by companies such as JD Power & Associates, maintains that brand perception is vital.
The brand, the product of Porsche's racing heritage, 'is the most important reason to buy a Porsche', chief executive Matthias Mueller has said.
Porsche sales chief Bernhard Maier said the company was not neglecting its sports-car line but was creating demand with new models after revamped versions of the 911 and Boxster roadster reached showrooms in December and in April.
A new version of the hardtop Cayman two-seater will be launched later this year, and the 918 Spyder - a €768,000 plug-in hybrid supercar - will arrive next year, he said.
Mr Helmut Becker, a former chief economist at BMW who now runs a consulting firm in Munich, said Porsche's new-found passion for big cars made business sense, even if it turns away purists.
'Two-seater sports cars are completely uneconomical, their customer base is shrinking,' he said. 'Even a classical sports-car maker has a right to broaden its portfolio.'
Back in the Berlin dealership, real estate manager Wilke directed his scorn at a Panamera sedan, a car that at first glance looks like a 911 that has been elongated.
'The Panamera is too big and too compromised,' he said. 'It simply lacks the timeless fascination of a 911. That's what Porsche is all about.'
'Two-seater sports cars are completely uneconomical, their customer base is shrinking. Even a classical sports-car maker has a right to broaden its portfolio.'
Mr Helmut Becker, former chief economist at BMW, on Porsche?s new-found passion for big cars