Civil servant started investing at 22, with $50k from NS and temp jobs
Instead of spending excessive sums of money on material desires, civil servant Chan Choon Yuan prefers to spend most of his time on investing and personal finance.
The avid reader of this column is so dedicated to encouraging financial literacy that he started blogging at Investmoolah in August last year while in between jobs.
Mr Chan, 28, also took accounting modules while he was studying at the Singapore Management University so that he could better understand financial statements, even though he was then a political science student. His academic background has helped him tie in what he learns about the world and the economy, but a large part of it was achieved through self-study.
"When you study more about finance, business and the economy, you learn that every sector is cyclical, except for utilities and transport," he said, noting that even banks are cyclical stocks as can be seen when they are hit by non-performing loans.
He also pored over online forums to learn how firms, including banks, work. "Over time, you become familiar with things and investing becomes common sense. But I'm not a seasoned investor yet because I haven't gone through a recession," he gamely admits.
Mr Chan, who started investing at 22 with $50,000 he'd saved from National Service, as a tutor and temporary jobs, uses fundamental analysis to pick his stocks, after flirting briefly with trading.
"When I first started, I saw a lot of research reports on online brokering platforms, but they were mostly penny stocks. I'd listened to some of the research reports, which didn't turn out well and that's when I learnt that I prefer fundamental analysis."
It also allows him to sleep soundly at night as he is certain of the reasons behind his stock selections.
His only regret is not having started investing at an even younger age, giving himself more time to learn from his mistakes.
He cites the Rule of 72 - known as such in finance because at 10 per cent interest, money would double every 7.2 years. It helps you work out when your money will double at a given interest rate, assuming the interest is compounded.
Worst and best bets
Q What has been your biggest investing mistake?
A The first few times I bought stocks after reading brokerage reports. For instance, one of the stocks was Renewable Energy Asia, which makes wind-turbine components.
I bought it at 20 cents, and it fell to 11 cents. When brokerage charges are added, my loss was more than 50 per cent.
Reports make stocks sound good and the sectors they are in sound like they're booming. Don't follow what analysts say too much.
But you still have to read a lot for stocks on the Singapore Exchange, there's no running away from it. If you don't want to study them, stick to index funds, like the Straits Times Index exchange-traded fund (ETF). If you don't have enough passion and interest in investing, stick to passive investing in ETFs.
Q And what has been your best investment move?
A The now private SuperBowl Holdings, which is Hiap Hoe's sports and leisure arm, which I bought in February 2013. That's when I learnt investing through the balance sheet was much better.
I was reading some of the forums and also realised there was a property near SMU back then, held by SuperBowl. I learnt a lot of its properties were conservatively valued at cost from the 1980s and 1990s.
It also bought a Balestier site through Government Land Sales, which was also conservatively valued. It built a hotel and the price went up.
Looking at the balance sheet, even if it was forced to sell it, the price it could be sold at would definitely be higher. There would be revaluation gains.
I got lucky when it was privatised by Hiap Hoe later in 2013. I bought it at more than 40 cents, and sold at more than 70 cents. This was among the highest returns in the shortest timeframe.
If I had bought the stock in 2010 or 2011, I would have been stuck until 2013. Luck played a part, but at least I identified this one, thanks to my study of stocks.
"If I have a 4 per cent return, my money will double in 28 years. I'll have a longer timeframe to learn from my mistakes, make sure not to repeat them and enjoy my returns for a longer period."
Q Moneywise, what were your growing-up years like?
A I've always been frugal and saved a lot of my pocket money. I save about 70 per cent to 80 per cent of my pay cheque, and spend on food and transport.
I also used to be in a recreational running group called SMU Run. I prefer recreational running as it doesn't cost a thing.
Q How did you get interested in investing?
A My father was a bank executive and retired quite early - in his early 50s. I was curious about how he managed to do that, and learnt that he managed his money well. His returns were even better than from bank deposits or funds.
But he was investing during a period when Singapore was booming.
I learnt that in equity investing, over the long term, you'll be able to accumulate enough. The longer you invest, the less panicky you'll feel about managing your money.
Q Describe your investing strategy.
A Growth and value investing are my cornerstones. I analyse the balance sheet, project the operating cash flow of the business, and check liquidity conditions with respect to when the firm's bonds mature.
For companies in troubled industries, I find out the liquidation worth of the company's assets.
Sometimes, I invest in companies without much analysis, but these are special situations.
Once I determine that a company has merits, I will use simple technical analysis to determine a good time to enter, such as a relative strength index below 30.
First, I look at macroeconomic factors, then choose the industry, and look at the alpha stocks or the better companies there.
On the balance sheet, I study the notes on the liabilities, how much interest the firm has to pay, when the bonds mature, and how the loans are structured.
For one of my earlier investments, I looked at the assets and realised they were quite conservative in their valuation. If the companies were to realise the assets, I knew it could reap gains.
After looking at the balance sheet, I compare the assets' values with the cash flow - and project whether the cash flow can meet the liabilities that are maturing.
Especially in times of crisis, I ask myself if the company I am investing in will be able to stay solvent three years from now, based on what I see on the balance sheet. When it comes to forecasting numbers, I use qualitative factors.
Q What's in your portfolio?
A About 45 per cent is in five stocks now, 15 per cent in P2P (peer-to-peer) investments, and the rest in cash and short-term cash equivalents. The total net worth is about $250,000 which fluctuates because of the stocks.
FOCUS ON GROWTH
Growth and value investing are my cornerstones. I analyse the balance sheet, project the operating cash flow of the business, and check liquidity conditions with respect to when the firm's bonds mature.
CIVIL SERVANT CHAN CHOON YUAN, on his investing strategy
My one-year returns are about a negative 25 per cent because of my holdings in Penguin and Ezion, which are affected by the current oil crisis.
But my five-year returns are about 21 per cent, or a 4 per cent compounded annual growth rate, boosted by lucky investments such as Valuetronics, Global Invacom, SuperBowl Holdings and KSH.
I also hold stocks in steel specialist TTJ Holdings. I'd invested in it after graduation. It is a good company in terms of management, cash flow-generating ability and its balance sheet. For Penguin Holdings, an offshore support company, the balance sheet was strong.
I'm just trying out P2P investments. An Epicentre Holdings bond makes up one of the biggest portion of my P2P investments so far. It gives an annual return of about 7 per cent to 8 per cent. I've another seven months left and hope there will be no defaults. As a bond-holder, the balance sheet is the most important.
Q What's the most extravagant thing you have done?
A That will be an upcoming trip in three months' time to Iceland and Norway for about $4,000. I am splurging on the trip as my friend says it will be our last chance to see the aurora borealis (Northern Lights) before the phenomenon starts a cyclical fade.
Q How are you planning for retirement?
A My target now is $2 million. Since I'm actively investing, I have term insurance. I'm covered under a group term plan for $150,000 and a personal accident group plan.
Term plans are much cheaper than whole-life plans and, returns-wise, I prefer investing on my own. If you invest on your own, or in an index - which requires less effort - you can earn more than from a whole-life plan, if you do it right.
The funds behind whole-life or endowment plans are also invested in stocks, bonds and properties, so I wonder if we can replicate that ourselves.
I'd substitute bonds with voluntary contributions to the CPF Special Account, and the equity component with the STI ETF.
Q Home is now…
A A Housing Board flat in Pasir Ris with my parents.
A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Sunday Times on August 21, 2016, with the headline 'His only regret? Not learning to invest sooner'. Print Edition | Subscribe
We have been experiencing some problems with subscriber log-ins and apologise for the inconvenience caused. Until we resolve the issues, subscribers need not log in to access ST Digital articles. But a log-in is still required for our PDFs.