India-China tensions rising amid blame game over border rows

China blames India for trespassing, while New Delhi accuses Beijing of blocking patrols

Tensions between India and China are spiking along their undemarcated border, with analysts in India examining if this could be part of a larger pattern of Chinese assertiveness, or if it is a local flare-up gone wrong.

Indian and Chinese soldiers have been involved in two skirmishes - one in the north-eastern state of Sikkim, and the other in the union territory of Ladakh.

In Naku La, Sikkim, on May 10, Chinese and Indian soldiers pelted stones at each other and traded blows, resulting in minor injuries to four Indian and seven Chinese soldiers. In the other scuffle, troops clashed in the night between May 5 and 6 on the northern bank of the Pangong Tso Lake, which extends from Ladakh to the Tibetan Autonomous Region.

While talks between the local militaries were initiated and both countries have so far underlined how dialogue is crucial to resolving disagreements, tensions have remained amid troop build-ups by both sides in the two areas.

China has blamed India for trespassing, while India has accused China of blocking its patrols.

Dr Jabin Jacob, associate professor at Shiv Nadar University, said: "The incident in Sikkim took place along a settled boundary and in really difficult terrain, which means the Chinese are pushing aggressively to undermine their own commitments made to India on Sikkim being a part of India.

"Overall, it can be read as part of a larger Chinese assertiveness that doesn't respect territorial integrity of other nations.

"Once incidents on the LAC (Line of Actual Control) scale up, with the involvement of higher authorities in the respective capitals, then I think we can believe that things will move more cautiously; these incidents will hopefully not turn into flash points."

The flare-ups are unusual because they involved physical fighting and stone pelting, and come at a time when China has been blamed for the coronavirus pandemic by the United States and tensions have been rising in the South China Sea.

India has accused China of being the aggressor.

"All Indian activities are entirely on the Indian side of the LAC. In fact, it is the Chinese side that has recently undertaken activity hindering India's normal patrolling patterns," said India's Ministry of External Affairs spokesman Anurag Srivastava.

"(The) Indian side remains firmly committed to work for the common objective of maintenance of peace and tranquillity in border areas. This is an essential prerequisite to the further development of Indian-China bilateral relations."

The two neighbours have an uneasy relationship because of Beijing's growing presence in India's neighbourhood and due to a festering dispute in several areas along their 4,000km-long border.

China claims the north-eastern state of Arunachal Pradesh, which has been in Indian hands since British days, as its own.

And India says China's occupation of Aksai Chin, 38,000 sq km of territory in Ladakh, is illegal.

In 2017, a 74-day border stand-off between their militaries in Doklam, an area strategically close to India's Silliguri Corridor, had threatened bilateral ties.

The issue was resolved through diplomacy, with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi travelling to Wuhan in central China for an informal summit with President Xi Jinping.

The two sides agreed on "strategic guidance to their respective militaries" to strengthen communication and build trust.

Still, special representative talks on the border, which have been on-going since the 1990s, have had little progress.

"The interruption in serious border negotiations in the past six or seven years has left the two militaries scrambling for minor tactical advantages in the disputed zones along the Line of Actual Control," said Dr Zorawar Daulet Singh, a historian and strategist in New Delhi.

"If this trend is not arrested by the political leaderships, such crises will one day escalate into an armed clash."

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on May 23, 2020, with the headline India-China tensions rising amid blame game over border rows. Subscribe