Moranbong: 5 things about the North Korean girl band's cancelled China performance

Members of the Moranbong Band of North Korea arrive at Beijing International Airport before departing from Beijing, China on Dec 12, 2015.
Members of the Moranbong Band of North Korea arrive at Beijing International Airport before departing from Beijing, China on Dec 12, 2015. PHOTO: REUTERS
Members of the Moranbong Band of North Korea arrive at Beijing International Airport before departing from Beijing.
Members of the Moranbong Band of North Korea arrive at Beijing International Airport before departing from Beijing.PHOTO: KYODO
Members of Moranbong talking outside the hotel they are staying at in Beijing.
Members of Moranbong talking outside the hotel they are staying at in Beijing. PHOTO: AFP

Moranbong, a North Korean pop group formed by leader Kim Jong Un, abruptly cancelled a Beijing tour on Saturday (Dec 12) and headed home hours before they were due to perform.

They went to the Beijing airport and boarded a flight whose departure was delayed for several hours, BBC said.

Xinhua said the cancellation was due to "communications issues at the working level", but this did not quell intense speculation about the state of China-North Korean ties.

Here are some theories why they withdrew and the buzz about the band:

1. Kim affronted by low-level audience


Members of Moranbong walking out of their hotel in Beijing on Dec 11, 2015. PHOTO: AFP

South Korea's Yonhap news agency said the North Koreans may have cancelled the show after China decided to send a lower ranking delegation than promised, Reuters reported.

The snub was probably due to Mr Kim's claim last week that the North possesses a hydrogen bomb. Experts have dismissed his claim as unlikely.

The Yonhap report cited an unnamed source as saying the North had initially requested an audience that included President Xi Jinping or Premier Li Keqiang.

2. Media coverage?


Members of Moranbong carry their instruments as they leave a hotel in Beijing. PHOTO: REUTERS

One North Korea expert cited by The Guardian said that Kim may have taken offence at stories circulated by South Korean media about a rumoured past relationship between Kim and a prominent member of the band.

 

The gossip also made its rounds on Chinese social media.

China agreed instead to send one of 25 politburo members, but then decided to send lower-ranking officials.

Yonhap reported that the stories about Ms Hyon Song Wol undermined the "dignity" of the North Korean leader.

Reports also said that Chinese netizens dubbed the band Kim's "imperial harem".

3. Censorship, mourning?


Members of Moranbong wait inside the lobby of a hotel in Beijing. PHOTO: REUTERS

Another contributing factor may have been requests from the Chinese that the band tone down some of the more grandiose lyrics praising the ruling Kim family, The Telegraph reported.

Arirang News said that it could be related to a period of mourning in Pyongyang that was declared for late leader Kim Jong Il, during which singing and dancing were banned.

He died on December 17, 2011 and huge crowds in North Korea have marked his death anniversary since.

4. Widely-covered arrival


 Members of Moranbong arrive at the National Centre for the Performing Arts in Beijing on Dec 10, 2015. PHOTO: EPA

Although their performance was invite-only, the arrival of the band was covered widely and their rehearsal in Beijing was captured in a Reuters video.

Paparazzi photos were posted online of the girls in olive military-style winter coats.

Tickets for the China shows were reportedly sold on the black market for high prices, and the band was put up at a luxury hotel, reports said.

It was the first overseas performance for the band, which is known for its orchestral performances that involve electronic synthesizers, electric guitars and violins.

The band members are known to dress racily for North Korea, in mini-skirts and high heels, and are hugely popular with young North Koreans.

5. Rumours about Kim's ex-girlfriend


Hyon Song-wol (left) arrives at a Beijing hotel on Dec 11, 2015. PHOTO: EPA

In 2013, rumours circulated in South Korea that Kim's former girlfriend Hyon had been executed, along with about a dozen other North Korean performers for making "pornographic films".

Reports even said their family members watched as they were shot. But she resurfaced in a television broadcast in 2014 in which she saluted Mr Kim for his "heavenly trust and warm care in promoting the arts", the New York Times said.

A Yonhap report said that when asked about the rumours, Ms Hyon only grinned and said: "Where do you come from?"

Despite being pressed repeatedly by reporters, she was tight-lipped and got on an elevator instead.