'We are downgrading our efforts to eradicate crops - spraying - a policy we think is totally ineffectual', said Mr Holbrooke, the US regional envoy. -- PHOTO: REUTERS
WASHINGTON - THE United States is winding down efforts to destroy poppy in Afghanistan, the US regional envoy said on Wednesday, blaming the zealous US approach for pushing peasants toward the Taleban.
Long-term solution
GENERAL Chip Gregson, the assistant secretary of defence for Asia, said the long-term solution was to improve security and infrastructure in Afghanistan to allow more legitimate agriculture.
'Eradication by itself hurts the farmers,' Gen Gregson told the hearing. 'The people who are making money off the drug trade are not the subsistence farmers - they are the middlemen.' He cited as a model the success of Thailand in eliminating poppy in the once infamous 'Golden Triangle' bordering Laos and Myanmar.
Mr Richard Holbrooke, the special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan, said President Barack Obama's administration was making 'significant adjustments' from the previous George W. Bush administration in a bid to root out Islamic extremism.
'We are downgrading our efforts to eradicate crops - spraying - a policy we think is totally ineffectual', Mr Holbrooke testified before Congress. He said the money spared would be devoted to stopping trafficking, pursuing drug lords and helping farmers grow other crops.
'Hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars we've spent on crop eradication has not done any damage to the Taleban. On the contrary, it's helped them recruit,' Mr Holbrooke said.
'In my experience', the veteran US diplomat and negotiator said, 'this is the least effective program ever.' Afghanistan supplies 90 per cent of the world's heroin, much of which emanates from the southern province of Helmand, where Taleban-led insurgents are waging a bloody campaign against international and Afghan forces.
Critics, even within the Nato-led coalition in Afghanistan, have feared that the United States was pushing impoverished peasants to the Taleban by destroying their key cash crop while funding the extremists.
Mr Holbrooke said the Obama administration was instead focusing on ramping up agricultural aid to provide Afghans with alternative livelihoods.
But his view was challenged by Representative Mr Mark Souder, a member of Bush's Republican Party, who said Afghanistan was already 'the breadbasket of the world' until poppy became more lucrative. 'There has to be some disincentive to plant heroin in addition to an incentive to plant other crops', Mr Souder said. 'It will not suffice to say, 'Plant corn', when you can get incredible amounts more dollars' with poppy, he said.
Mr Antonio Costa, director of the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, said eradication of crops had not worked in Afghanistan and it was more effective to go after high-value targets such as laboratories.
Mr Costa, in Washington to present the annual UN report on drugs, said market forces were also helping. He said Afghanistan was producing double the world demand for opium - sending prices tumbling. 'We want basically conditions where prices are so low that farmers will turn to alternative crops', Mr Costa said. -- AFP
